Westworld showrunner breaks down season 4 timeline twist and Hale's "nefarious plan"

Tessa Thompson in Charlotte Hale in Westworld season 4
(Image credit: HBO)

The latest episode of Westworld season 4 has been described by fans as the HBO show's best since season 1. Full of shock reveals, 'Generation Loss' pulls the rug out from under its audience and confirms that they've been watching two timelines play out simultaneously – something that has deep repercussions for the human race and Aaron Paul's Caleb Nichols, in particular. 

As viewers rush to social media to sing episode 4's praises, showrunner Lisa Joy has broken down some of its biggest twists, and elaborated on big bad Charlotte Hale's "nefarious plan." Be warned, things are about to get spoiler-heavy.

To recap, in their attempt to evade the murderous Man in Black, Maeve (Thandiwe Newton) and Caleb (Aaron Paul) stumbled across some sort of control room below the mobster park they'd hidden themselves in. Via monitors, the pair watch as a group of humans appear to do things against their will. The subjects' final tasks? Kill themselves. Believing his young daughter Frankie was one of the human captives, Caleb broke into one of the chambers, only to find that Frankie was actually a host, and full of flies that then entered Caleb's body and started trying to control him. 

In episode 4, Hale (Tessa Thompson) explains to an incapacitated Caleb that she is using the sound-controlled flies – or parasites – to enslave the human attendees of the 1930s-set Temperance attraction. "She starts by testing it out in the park, but it’s also the ultimate place to start a plague from, because people from all over the world would go to Westworld, and then they bring that disease home with them," Joy elaborated in a new interview with The Wrap. "Nothing beats empathy quite like literalism when you're literally put in the shoes of the other person. And that’s what’s happened here."

Aaron Paul as Caleb Nichols in Westworld season 4

(Image credit: HBO)

That's just the tip of the iceberg, too. Hale also tells Caleb, after he witnesses Maeve blow herself up in an effort to stop the Man in Black, that he isn't actually a human anymore, he's a host, and that he died trying to stop her roll-out of the infection a whopping 23 years ago. Ever since, he's been forced to relive the run-up to his final moments but is actually in a futuristic New York City – much like the one occupied by Evan Rachel Wood's mysterious Christina.

"We've unfortunately seen, these epidemics can sometimes spread like wildfire and when you look at something as innocuous seeming as a fly or a mosquito and much of the world today, you realize how quickly we could disrupt human nature with the wrong virus.

"The fact that it takes, you know, a generation or so to kick into full effect to kind of critical mass is actually still incredibly fast if you think about a biological or political takeover," Joy continued, before teasing what's to come: "Hale has won and the humans in fact have been subjugated by this new A.I. power structure, I think we have to see how the fight for free will – this time waged by humans against robots – plays out. It's pretty fun. You see all of our actors doing what they do best, kicking ass and exploring their lives and the realities around them."

In learning that his human self has been "dead" for more than two decades, Caleb is met with the devastating realisation that his young daughter Frankie has grown up without him in episode 4. Turns out, Frankie became C, the desert-traversing ally of Bernard (Jeffrey Wright) and Stubbs (Luke Hemsworth). In their timeline, the trio are searching for Caleb's body. Instead, they stumble across Maeve's, and the prophetic Bernard explains to Frankie (Aurora Perrineau) that the deactivated host could prove to be the weapon that'll help them win the war against Hale.

Fortunately, we won't have to wait too much longer to find out whether that's the case. Westworld season 4 airs on HBO and HBO Max every Sunday, with each episode following a day later in the UK on Sky Atlantic and NOW TV. While we wait for the next, fill out your watch list with our picks of the best new TV shows coming our way, this year and beyond. 

Amy West

I am an Entertainment Writer here at 12DOVE, covering all things TV and film across our Total Film and SFX sections. Elsewhere, my words have been published by the likes of Digital Spy, SciFiNow, PinkNews, FANDOM, Radio Times, and Total Film magazine.

Read more
Pedro Pascal as Joel in The Last of Us season 2 first look
The Last of Us season 2 release date, cast, plot, trailer, and more news
Rebecca Ferguson as Juliette and Steve Zahn as Solo in the Silo season 2 finale
Silo season 2 ending explained: Does Juliette make it back? What is the safeguard procedure? What's the deal with that last scene?
Severance season 2 trailer
Severance season 2: Release dates, episodes, review, and everything you need to know about Apple TV Plus show's return
Ncuti Gatwa as the Doctor and Nicola Coughlan as Joy in the 2024 Doctor Who Christmas special
Doctor Who 2024 Christmas special ending explained: who dies, is Ruby Sunday in it, and what is the Star Seed?
Severance
I visited the set of Severance season 2 and it was a perfect, dystopian dream that serves as a reminder that "the work is mysterious and important"
Kaitlyn Dever as Abby in The Last Of Us season 2
I'm really hopeful that The Last of Us season 2 flips a key part of the game's story – and I think the new trailer just confirmed it
Latest in Sci-Fi Shows
Alien Earth teaser
New Alien: Earth teaser introduces us to new cast members and the cutest little cat – and if a Xenomorph eats it, I will be furious
The Last of Us
The Last of Us season 2 is giving a game character the Bill and Frank treatment – and he's so deep-cut you might barely remember him
The Last of Us season 2 first look
Pedro Pascal says "beautiful" scene that made him want to join The Last of Us got cut, but it’ll thankfully appear in season 2: "He was like, ‘That’s half the reason I’m here!’"
Diego Luna in Andor
It looks like a key Star Wars event mentioned in Rebels will be shown in Andor season 2
Ncuti Gatwa in Doctor Who season 2
Doctor Who fans think they've spotted a tease for surprise villains in new season 2 trailer
The Xenomorph in Alien: Earth
New look at Alien: Earth has fans theorizing over whether they can hear a Predator in the background
Latest in News
Balatro
Balatro creator started "properly playing the game myself about a week before launch" and had "a pretty emotional moment" where he realized it's "actually fun"
Death Stranding 2 Collector's Edition
Hideo Kojima reveals Death Stranding 2: On the Beach release date, and the Collector's Edition includes exactly what I predicted it would
Kingmakers
Kingmakers is a strategy game about taking on medieval armies with a gun, but its devs thought the giant mech was too much
The Witcher 3 lead says "not many games" were trying to match the RPG back in 2015, and that meant "there was a risk" to making it in the first place
The Blood of Dawnwalker
The Witcher 3 dev says his new vampire RPG Blood of Dawnwalker wants to challenge genre conventions, but only if "we're changing them to actually achieve some goal"
Daredevil recap: The Defenders
Marvel fans are discussing which of the Netflix series characters would have survived the Blip