We might've gotten a very different Baldur's Gate 3, but a "shattering" review bomb broke up the team that would've made it

Baldur's Gate 3
(Image credit: Larian)

Baldur's Gate 3 could have been a completely different game from a completely different studio, if not for a review bomb that shattered the team which would've made it.

The two original Baldur's Gate games were developed by the legendary RPG studio BioWare. Many years later, BioWare co-founder Trent Oster would head up an indie studio called Beamdog as it created the Enhanced Edition remasters for both games. In 2016, Beamdog tried its hand at creating some new content for Baldur's Gate with Siege of Dragonspear, an expansion pack that bridges the gap between the first two games.

Siege of Dragonspear received mixed reviews from players, but the negative responses grew in volume and vitriol for two reasons: the expansion included an off-handed joke referencing the Gamergate harassment campaign, and a minor character named Mizhena who revealed in dialog that she's transgender. Angry gamers threw threats and harassment at Beamdog, prompting a condemnatory response from Oster at the time. The studio cut the Gamergate line and expanded Mizhena's dialog, but the damage to the team had been done.

"We were sailing down the river and then all the cannons opened up so we just shut all the hatches," Oster said in a recent interview for Epic. "And you could hear cannonballs bang the hull, and everybody was just huddled down inside. It basically fractured that team. At Beamdog today we have one person remaining from that team. Everyone else is gone. It drove some of them out of the industry. It drove others to seek completely different kinds of games to work on. It was a shattering experience."

Oster said, "With another game under their belt, that team could have done something amazing. But that team doesn’t exist anymore. And that’s one of the reasons that we weren’t able to do a Baldur’s Gate 3. Literally, that team was in the process of slowly collapsing."

Of course, the Baldur's Gate 3 we did get is absolutely incredible, and in a delightfully ironic twist the new RPG turned out to be very sexually inclusive as well. But it's still heartbreaking that this team never got the chance to to build another original take on classic RPGs - especially since, as Oster has noted, there were pitches for a sequel to Planescape: Torment, which remains arguably the best RPG ever made.

Unfortunately, there's been another sad note in the Beamdog story since Oster's interview. Beamdog is now owned by Aspyr Media, a subsidiary of the beleaguered Embracer Group, and last week, 26 developers were laid off from the small studio according to a report from Game Developer. The layoffs follow the 1.0 launch of the studio's most recent game, MythForce, a co-op roguelike inspired by Saturday morning cartoons like the '80s Dungeons & Dragons series.

Check out the story of the making of Baldur's Gate.

Dustin Bailey
Staff Writer

Dustin Bailey joined the GamesRadar team as a Staff Writer in May 2022, and is currently based in Missouri. He's been covering games (with occasional dalliances in the worlds of anime and pro wrestling) since 2015, first as a freelancer, then as a news writer at PCGamesN for nearly five years. His love for games was sparked somewhere between Metal Gear Solid 2 and Knights of the Old Republic, and these days you can usually find him splitting his entertainment time between retro gaming, the latest big action-adventure title, or a long haul in American Truck Simulator.

Read more
The key art for Baldur's Gate 3 showing dragons and the Nautilus, with Karlach standing in the foreground, weapon in hand
The Making of Baldur's Gate 3: "We really wanted to make it so that even if you don't know D&D or Baldur's Gate, you would still have exciting choices as a player"
Baldur's Gate 3 companion Shadowheart, a young woman with braided black hair and plated armor, smirking while glancing to the side
Baldur's Gate 3's Swen Vincke, feeling all "nostalgic," teases the "the story ain't over" for Larian Studios' "incredible journey"
Disco Elysium
Baldur's Gate 3 Karlach actor hits out at RPG devs trying to recruit them for their Disco Elysium successors: "Miss me with that casting call"
Baldur's Gate 3 screenshot showing Astarion, a pale male elf with short curly white hair and red eyes, looking over his shoulder with a smirk on his face
As the "incredible journey" to Baldur's Gate 3 wraps up, Larian Studios has its "full attention" on its next RPG: "The story ain't over yet"
Planescape: Torment
Planescape: Torment was a revolutionary RPG, but many of its devs had no experience with the D&D campaign it was based on: "What the f*ck is that?"
Baldur's gate 3 screenshot of a playermade tav and Gale in the background
Baldur's Gate 3 has changed so much in 2024 that I wish the RPG could be my GOTY again this year
Latest in RPG
Atomfall screenshot
Fallout: New Vegas is a big inspiration for Atomfall, which is why you’ll be able to kill every NPC in post-apocalyptic Cumbria
Assassin's Creed Shadows cinematic screenshot
Assassin's Creed Shadows' transmog looks set to combine the best of Odyssey and Vahalla to make changing my drip easier than ever
Stardew Valley Baldur's Gate 3 mod Baldur's Village
Baldur's Gate 3 director Swen Vincke gives his official approval to the Stardew Valley mod that brings the D&D RPG to Pelican Town
The Witcher 3 lead says "not many games" were trying to match the RPG back in 2015, and that meant "there was a risk" to making it in the first place
The Blood of Dawnwalker
The Witcher 3 dev says his new vampire RPG Blood of Dawnwalker wants to challenge genre conventions, but only if "we're changing them to actually achieve some goal"
The Blood of Dawnwalker: A screenshot of the vampire Brencis holding up a crown during the trailer for the upcoming game.
The Witcher 3 devs created a Jekyll & Hyde-style character for their new vampire RPG "because nobody yet has done that"
Latest in News
Diego Luna as Cassian Andor in Andor season 2
Andor season 2 showrunner Tony Gilroy breaks silence on the weird release schedule: "It's a Disney decision"
Jordan A. Mun looks at herself in a mirror in just a vest in Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet screenshot
5 years after starting development, Neil Druckmann says Naughty Dog's new game Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet is "still evolving and changing as we're making it"
Silent Hill f
After 2 years of silence, the next mainline Silent Hill game is getting a dedicated stream this week with "the latest news"
Original Xbox console
Former Microsoft exec says the first Xbox was killed early in favor of 360 because it was "losing money left right and center," but luckily "we could afford to hemorrhage cash"
A Monster Hunter Wilds character holding binoculars.
Despite Monster Hunter Wilds suffering monstrous performance problems on PC, it still outsold the PS5 and Xbox Series X versions in the US
Jordan A. Mun looks at herself in a mirror in just a vest in Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet screenshot
The Last of Us creator Neil Druckmann says Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet will also be about "being lonely," as if his zombie apocalypse wasn’t isolating enough: "I really want you to be lost"