The Red Dead Redemption remake could pave the way for a return to Grand Theft Auto's best-ever story

GTA 4
(Image credit: Rockstar)

I've spent a lot of time with GTA 5 and its multiplayer offshoot, GTA Online. In fact, the last time I checked, I'd clocked well over 2,000 hours roving around in Los Santos. From its Dr Dre-starring The Contract expansion, to its thriving roleplay scene on PC, I can still lose myself for hours at a time whenever I visit today. But GTA 4 is better. 

In both entertainment value and legacy terms, Grand Theft Auto 4 is not only better than its long-serving, hugely-successful successor, but, for me, it's the very best of the 26-year-spanning crime sim series. I'm likewise fond of Rockstar's wider back catalog, not least L.A. Noire, Manhunt, Bully and, of course, Red Dead Redemption and its sequel. But Niko Bellic's beleaguered American adventure in Liberty City is a cut above. 

As you may have spied this week, Rockstar is now bringing a Red Dead Redemption port (or "conversion", as it's being officially billed) to the Nintendo Switch and PS4 for the first time. And given the fact RDR and GTA 4 are powered by the same RAGE engine, I now can't stop thinking about Niko and his pseudo New York City stomping ground getting the same treatment.

If I can make it here

GTA 4

(Image credit: Rockstar)

When the news dropped this week, we asked: Why has Rockstar brought Red Dead Redemption to the Switch and PS4 in 2023, within which we explored the possible reasons for bringing such an old game, untouched, to last-gen hardware. Whether this Red Dead decision is a good or bad one is up for debate (I myself quite fancy working through Undead Nightmare on the couch; but the price tag has clearly upset some would-be players), but, putting Red Dead itself to one side, from a logistical point of view it means we could see GTA 4 brought forward in the same way. 

Following in the footsteps of GTA 3 (2001), GTA: Vice City (2002), and GTA: San Andreas (2004), GTA 4 marked a new dawn for the Grand Theft Auto series when it landed in 2008. Powered by the PS3 and Xbox 360, it was the first game set in the series' 'HD Universe', evolving the previous games' cartoon-like aesthetic into something grittier and more realistic.

GTA 4

(Image credit: Rockstar)

"I would bite your hand off for a fully-realized, from-the-ground-up retelling of GTA 4 in faux NYC, but with GTA 6 hopefully not too far off now, I imagine there's less than zero chance of that happening."

While darkly funny throughout, Niko Bellic's story was a complex one; of an immigrant chasing the American dream and getting sidetracked into a life of crime, whose desperate circumstances strived to justify his actions – even more so than those of bygone protagonists Carl Johnson and Tommy Vercetti. Red Dead Redemption certainly carried those visual and narrative tenets forward, but GTA 4's story always felt more grounded in reality given its modern day place in time. 

I would bite your hand off for a fully-realized, from-the-ground-up retelling of GTA 4 in faux NYC, but with GTA 6 hopefully not too far off now, I imagine there's less than zero chance of that happening. Which is fine – I'm as excited about the next mainline Grand Theft Auto game as the next person – but with the OG Red Dead Redemption pretty much totally unexpectedly heading to the Switch, why shouldn't GTA 4 follow suit? As it stands, GTA 4 boasts 'Playable' status on the Steam deck, as opposed to 'Verified', meaning while it works on Valve's PC-inspired handheld, it's not designed to work seamlessly with the hardware's interface and settings. 

The Grand Theft Auto Trilogy: Definitive Edition was criticized at launch in late 2021 by some players who experienced game-breaking bugs and crashes. At one stage the game was pulled from sale, and a series of fixes and patches were applied in the intervening weeks and months. Running on the Renderware engine, I'd always hoped Bully might have received the same modern day upscaling, but the Definitive Edition's troubles have since made that feel unlikely.  

All of that said, If Double Eleven Studio succeeds in porting the Wild West to Nintendo's current flagship console without issue, then I do hope they turn their attention to the game that made Red Dead Redemption possible. Niko Bellic has his American dream. And I have mine. 


Here are 10 games like GTA you need to play while waiting for GTA 6

Joe Donnelly
Contributor

Joe Donnelly is a sports editor from Glasgow and former features editor at 12DOVE. A mental health advocate, Joe has written about video games and mental health for The Guardian, New Statesman, VICE, PC Gamer and many more, and believes the interactive nature of video games makes them uniquely placed to educate and inform. His book Checkpoint considers the complex intersections of video games and mental health, and was shortlisted for Scotland's National Book of the Year for non-fiction in 2021. As familiar with the streets of Los Santos as he is the west of Scotland, Joe can often be found living his best and worst lives in GTA Online and its PC role-playing scene.

Read more
A player holding a gun in GTA Liberty City Stories
GTA 6 could learn a weird thing or two from Rockstar's most unloved PSP game
A player holding a gun in GTA Liberty City Stories
GTA: Liberty City Stories and Vice City Stories deserve the Definitive Edition treatment
GTA Vice City
Former GTA dev weighs in on Rockstar's attempt to silence Vice City mod that ports the whole game to GTA 4: "This is what companies are supposed to do"
GTA 6 reveal trailer screenshot showing a young blonde woman standing near a sunny rooftop pool, wearing a white and gold bikini
Rockstar, please: I need GTA 6's map to have more of San Andreas' backwater bliss
GTA 4
Veteran GTA dev says Rockstar should make a GTA 4 remaster, but "it would be better" if it was a "quality remaster" this time
Players in GTA Online running businesses and playing missions
It sounds like GTA Online could have a life after GTA 6 – but after 400 hours in Los Santos, I'm ready to say goodbye
Latest in Action
Death Stranding 2: On the Beach
Dark Souls 2 fans remind Death Stranding 2 director Hideo Kojima that he won’t be taking the DS2 acronym that easily
Death Stranding 2
Hideo Kojima says Death Stranding's themes of connection came about because "I thought I lost everything when I became alone nine years ago"
Beyond the Ice Palace 2
After 37 years, this Commodore 64 classic returns with a new Metroidvania sequel that gives serious old-school Castlevania vibes
Fortnite's Lara croft skin in front of a building
Fortnite has had Tomb Raider's Lara Croft locked away in battle pass exclusivity jail for almost 4 years, but she's reportedly getting a new skin very soon
The Last of Us 2
The Last of Us creator Neil Druckmann sounds like he's contemplating the end of his career: "When is it time to stop?"
Screenshot of Neil in Death Stranding 2
Hideo Kojima says he chose Death Stranding 2's Solid Snake lookalike because he needed an actor who "would surpass" Mads Mikkelsen
Latest in Features
The Witcher 3 screenshot of Geralt
Avowed and Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 tap into the same thing that makes The Witcher 3 so compelling – and it's something I'm always looking for in RPGs
Marvel Rivals Spider-Man
Spider-Man has become every Marvel Rivals player's worst nightmare
The Punisher holding two machine guns in the rain
Daredevil: Born Again - Learn the bullet-riddled comic book history of the Punisher before he officially joins the MCU
A woman in a underwater machine waving during the cinematic teaser for Subnautica 2.
Subnautica 2: Everything we know about the new underwater survival game
The AMD Ryzen 7 8700G being held above a motherboard by a reviewer
AMD's pro-consumer 9070 strategies are exactly why it's primed to dominate the CPU market in 2025
Assassin's Creed Shadows cinematic screenshot
Assassin's Creed Shadows' transmog looks set to combine the best of Odyssey and Vahalla to make changing my drip easier than ever