The Adam Project's CGI has left Netflix users baffled

Ryan Reynolds and Zoe Saldana in The Adam Project
(Image credit: Netflix)

Whether you loved or hated The Adam Project, there seems to be one specific factor in the film that everyone can agree on: the strange use of CGI, specifically in a scene involving Oscar nominee Catherine Keener.

The movie stars Ryan Reynolds as the titular Adam, a fighter pilot from a dystopian 2050 who attempts to travels back in time to the year 2018, but crash lands in 2022 and meets his 12-year-old self. Catherine Keener plays Maya Sorian, the villainous leader of the dystopian world who attempts to capture Adam and bring him back to 2050.

Halfway through the film, Maya goes back in time to visit her younger self. Rather than use makeup or hairstyling to create a young Keener, the film uses CGI to project a flat, one-dimensional 'deep fake' onto Keener's face. Many took umbrage with this choice, with more viewers tweeting about the deep fake than about Keener's actual performance.

"The Adam Project is on Netflix and it’s a pretty great movie," one Twitter user said. "It also has one of the worst de-aging CG effects I’ve ever seen."

"If, somehow, the de-aged CGI Catherine Keener from The Adam Project could be captured holding the baby from American Sniper, time might stop and the universe would fold in on itself and collapse," another joked.

One user said he "didn't hate" the film, but that he'd "rather forgive a slightly different looking actress than a wonky CGI."

New York Times film critic Natalia Winkelman shared her review, calling it "a movie that loves it some Ryan Reynolds banter and de-ages Catherine Keener into a constipated Sim." Others seemed to echo this opinion.

Writer James Marsh compared the CGI to that of The Irishman, in which a young Robert De Niro is depicted onscreen, saying The Adam Project "confirms" that Netflix has made little effort to improve its VFX. "For a film about future tech," he added. "Its own effects work is horrendous."

One user commented on the differences between aging in films, and how typically much more effort is put into the appearance of a female character: "The Adam Project isn’t at all noteworthy except that the CGI they did for the younger version of Catherine Keener feels straight-up insulting. They did all that to try to make a beautiful woman look barely younger and all Ryan Reynolds did was shave his beard?"

"Does The Adam Project not think I don't know what Catherine Keener looked like 30 years ago?" someone asked. "Did they not consult, like, Being John Malkovich before applying the de-aging CGI?"

Another went so far as to call the de-aging of Keener's character a "ghoulish deep fake nightmare." 

The Adam Project is currently streaming on Netflix. For more, check out our breakdown of how time travel works in The Adam Project.

Lauren Milici
Senior Writer, Tv & Film

Lauren Milici is a Senior Entertainment Writer for 12DOVE currently based in the Midwest. She previously reported on breaking news for The Independent's Indy100 and created TV and film listicles for Ranker. Her work has been published in Fandom, Nerdist, Paste Magazine, Vulture, PopSugar, Fangoria, and more.

Read more
Millie Bobby Brown and Chris Pratt in The Electric State
The Electric State review: "Although this may be their most visually stunning movie yet, it looks like the Russos are yet to find their footing outside of the MCU"
Millie Bobby Brown in The Electric State trailer
The Russo Brothers and The Electric State cast talk the Netflix movie's "stunning" VFX – and say the graphic novel's creator is "fully supportive" of the movie lightening the tone
Shrek 5 teaser
Everyone is saying the same thing about the new Shrek 5 teaser – why does Fiona look like that?
Giancarlo Esposito in The Electric State
The Electric State may be the Russo brothers' most challenging VFX project yet, but stars Stanley Tucci and Giancarlo Esposito say it's one of the easiest films they’ve ever done
Jesse Plemons and Robert De Niro in Zero Day
Robert De Niro's new Netflix series is being called everything from "addictive" to "dull" as it debuts to mixed reviews and a low Rotten Tomatoes score
Millie Bobby Brown, Chris Pratt, and Ke Huy Quan in The Electric State
$320 million in the hole, the Russo brothers' new Netflix movie debuts to their worst Rotten Tomatoes score even though it's one of the most expensive films ever made
Latest in Sci-Fi Movies
Scarlett Johansson in Jurassic World Rebirth
Jurassic World Rebirth studio asked Scarlett Johansson to join Instagram, but she refused: "The film will do fine"
The Rise of Skywalker
Despite those retirement reports, Lucasfilm boss Kathleen Kennedy is "very involved" in the Rey Star Wars movie, according to Daisy Ridley
The Iron Mask
The 32 greatest swashbuckler movies ever made
Giancarlo Esposito in The Electric State
The Electric State star Giancarlo Esposito explains why adapting the bleak novel into a family friendly adventure was the right decision: "I'm going to bring my children with me"
Giancarlo Esposito in The Electric State
The Electric State may be the Russo brothers' most challenging VFX project yet, but stars Stanley Tucci and Giancarlo Esposito say it's one of the easiest films they’ve ever done
Giancarlo Esposito and Stanley Tucci in The Electric State
Stars Stanley Tucci and Giancarlo Esposito say their new dystopian sci-fi movie The Electric State is more like our own reality than we might realize
Latest in News
Scarlett Johansson in Jurassic World Rebirth
Jurassic World Rebirth studio asked Scarlett Johansson to join Instagram, but she refused: "The film will do fine"
Deltarune
Undertale creator Toby Fox's tomfoolery leaves Deltarune testers thinking an intentional nerf was actually a bug after they "independently" discovered it
Pokemon Go player trying to catch a Croagunk
Pokemon Go developer Niantic has been bought for $3.5 billion, CEO says it'll help its games be "'forever games' that will endure for future generations"
A Minecraft Movie
Minecraft movie's popcorn bucket is an explosive, game-accurate continuation of a cinema trend that shows no signs of slowing down
The Running Man
The Running Man reboot is bringing back key aspects of Stephen King's novel to turn it into "the deadliest game of hide and seek"
Balatro Joker card
After stepping away from Balatro for 3 months, the developer only resumed work "because I was bored but the internet was out so I couldn't play Rocket League"