Why you can trust 12DOVE
Neil Jordan has made some cracking films in his time. Just look at his latest, The Good Thief, a languid piece of Gallic class. So it comes as something of a disappointment that his premise about two actors masquerading as gangsters should be so mismoulded by another's clumsy hands.
Jordan's concept is a simple one: desperate for cash, a pair of jobbing Dublin thesps, O'Malley (Michael Caine) and Tom (Black Books' Dylan Moran), conspire to rob crim Barreller (Michael Gambon). Their plan? To impersonate a debt-collecting gang. Not the brightest idea, maybe, and things inevitably go wrong, O'Malley and Tom soon incurring the wrath of the real crooks. Their only hope of escape is to pose as a plethora of characters, but Tom falling for Barreller's daughter (Lena Headey) doesn't help...
Writer/director Conor McPherson previously wrote the criminally underseen I Went Down. Here, he's out of his depth, taking Jordan's concept and turning it into a farce with few laughs and an almost pathological misuse of talent.
Yes, some scenes amuse (Caine's appalling Shakespearean acting is a must-see), but McPherson's script soon spirals down the plughole as it tries to leapfrog between romantic comedy and black humour.
A more seasoned lead would have helped, but Moran's inexperience is evident as he bumbles through scene after scene. And poor old Headey is stranded too, left to kick her heels in her now customary role of `tacked-on love interest in regional comedy'.
Still, at least she gets some decent screen time. Miranda Richardson, on the other hand, is woefully underused as the Mob boss. Why employ a great actress and reduce her to a bit part?
The Total Film team are made up of the finest minds in all of film journalism. They are: Editor Jane Crowther, Deputy Editor Matt Maytum, Reviews Ed Matthew Leyland, News Editor Jordan Farley, and Online Editor Emily Murray. Expect exclusive news, reviews, features, and more from the team behind the smarter movie magazine.
I'm 100% sure that Arcane season 2 has introduced the next League of Legends champion, and I can't wait for them
What happened to Jinx at the end of Arcane? A tiny animation detail and a massive throwback could explain Powder's fate
The Final Fantasy 7 Remake team's 10 years working together puts it "in a really great position to move forward and do something even greater" once the trilogy wraps