Sony responds to reports Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield could return in Spider-Man 3

(Image credit: Sony/Marvel)

An official statement from Sony Pictures, the studio behind the Spider-Man movies, has debunked reports claiming Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield would both return as Peter Parker in Tom Holland’s Spider-Man 3

The rumours – which claimed the two former Spider-Men would return thanks to some multiverse shenanigans – were widely circulated online, but ET Canada has since received word from Sony that no casting has been confirmed.

“Those rumoured castings are not confirmed,” the studio statement reads. Notice, however, that there’s no outright denial that Maguire and Garfield could be back…

While the idea of the two actors reprising their roles once seemed like ludicrous fan-casting, recent reports that Benedict Cumberbatch’s Doctor Strange will be Parker’s mentor in Spider-Man 3, and that Jamie Foxx is reprising his Electro role, have implied a live-action Spider-Verse could be on the cards.

The original report suggested that Maguire and Garfield could appear in Spider-Man 3 and that they would arrive in the final act to help Holland defeat Electro, who would be joined by other Spider-Man villains. But, as the studio noted, this isn’t confirmed, so take it with a webbed-fistful of salt.

If Electro arrives from another universe, who better to help the young Web-Slinger than a sorcerer familiar with alternate dimensions and magic? Hopefully, Cumberbatch’s role isn’t just as a replacement for Tony Stark after the hero’s defiant death in Avengers: Endgame. Stephen Strange’s sarcastic snarkiness has often been compared to Stark, so his dynamic with Parker could easily follow a similar path. 

Cameras roll on Spider-Man 3 in Atlanta this month as Cumberbatch also prepares to start work on Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness with director Sam Raimi. Jon Watts returns to helm Spider-Man 3 from a script penned by Chris McKenna and Erik Sommers. Marvel head honcho Kevin Feige is producing the sequel alongside Amy Pascal.

There’s still months to go until Black Widow arrives in cinemas after it was pushed to May 7 2021, but until then take a look at all the upcoming movies on the way in 2020 and beyond. 

Freelance Writer

Eammon is an experienced TV and movie journalist, who's written for Looper, Fandom, The Digital Fix, Radio Times, Zavvi, and GamesRadar over the years. 

Latest in Movies
Theo James as Hal in Osgood Perkins' The Monkey
It might only be March, but Stephen King adaptation The Monkey is now the highest grossing horror movie of 2025
Cyborg and Batman together
Justice League stars Ray Fisher and Ben Affleck are teaming up for new thriller Animals
Batman and Catwoman talking
Robert Pattinson is hoping to team up with his The Batman co-star Zoe Kravitz on another project soon
Keanu Reeves and Brzrkr
Justin Lin to helm Keanu Reeves' comic book movie adaptation BRZRKR for Netflix
Train to Busan passengers
Train to Busan director is returning to the horror sub-genre with a new movie described as the culmination of his zombie universe
Thomas Shelby on a horse
Although Netflix is making the Peaky Blinders movie, fans need not to worry as it will be released in theaters too
Latest in News
Daredevil recap: The Defenders
Marvel fans are discussing which of the Netflix series characters would have survived the Blip
A misty, forested mountainside in Prologue: Go Wayback!
PUBG creator's wilderness survival game actually draws inspiration from an unexpected place - a whole raft of zombie games like DayZ, Project Zomboid, and Left 4 Dead
The Blood of Dawnwalker: A screenshot of the vampire Brencis holding up a crown during the trailer for the upcoming game.
The Witcher 3 devs created a Jekyll & Hyde-style character for their new vampire RPG "because nobody yet has done that"
Charlie Cox as Matt Murdock in Daredevil: Born Again
Daredevil fans are wondering if Born Again season 2 will set up a darker comic book arc for Matt Murdock
Theo James as Hal in Osgood Perkins' The Monkey
It might only be March, but Stephen King adaptation The Monkey is now the highest grossing horror movie of 2025
Balatro screenshot showing an assortment of card packs
Balatro creator initially considered a Steam release in part to help "get a game developer job somewhere," and after 5 million sales I'd say he found one