This dark new Metroidvania is already 2024's second best-reviewed game, making it a perfect tonic to ease my Hollow Knight Silksong blues

Animal Well screenshot, captured on PC
(Image credit: Bigmode)

Hollow Knight Silksong is still somewhere behind the shadowy gates of game development, but not to worry, this banger year for Metroidvanias continues with Animal Well, out today, which might just be a game of the year contender based on its critical reception. 

Indie developer Billy Basso first began making Animal Well in 2017, before YouTuber videogamedunkey jumped in to help distribute the game with his fresh faced publisher Bigmode Games. (Animal Well is actually the company's first published game and what a way to get things started.)

The arduous wait seems to have paid off, though, as Animal Well is currently the second best-reviewed game this year, with an aggregate score of 91 according to Metacritic. Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth is the only other 2024 release ahead of the surprise indie, and barely so, with an average rating of 92. 

Reviews have been gushing about Animal Well's layered pixel art that doesn't just rely on nostalgia, puzzles, and secrets that continually reward creative thinking, and a natural world that seems to tick on whether you're there to witness it or not. 

"Animal Well is stubbornly traditional in keeping you in the dark as you embark on your adventure, but that's firmly to its credit as you unravel the mysteries sprinkled around its map," GamesRadar's Animal Well review reads. "Puzzles involving animals, toys and mechanical devices demand creative thinking, while the sense that nothing is quite as it seems never lets up. This is an endlessly inventive Metroidvania with unfathomable depth."

Animal Well is out now on Steam, Nintendo Switch, and PS5.

Ubisoft's Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown pivot, the ultra psychedelic Ultros, personal odyssey Tales of Kenzera: Zau, and now Animal Well have all made 2024 a killer year for the genre, with or without a certain subterranean goth bug showing up. And there are probably dozens of other gems buried under storefront algorithms that I sadly haven't discovered yet.

Check out our best Metroidvania games list for more. 

Freelance contributor

Kaan freelances for various websites including Rock Paper Shotgun, Eurogamer, and this one, Gamesradar. He particularly enjoys writing about spooky indies, throwback RPGs, and anything that's vaguely silly. Also has an English Literature and Film Studies degree that he'll soon forget.

Read more
Year in review: playing Balatro against The Eye challenge
From Balatro to Animal Well, here's the best indie games of 2024
Hollow Knight: Silksong
10 Games like Hollow Knight to play while you wait for Silksong
Thank Goodness You're Here screenshot of the lead character being lifted into the air by a jovial man
I cover indie games every week, and the likes of Balatro, Animal Well, and Thank Goodness You're Here have made 2024 an unforgettable year
Balatro Joker card
Balatro creator shares the GOTY love with other indie games while giving out a "very prestigious Golden Thunk award"
Beyond the Ice Palace 2 screenshots showing whip attacks
And you thought Hollow Knight: Silksong is late – 37 years in the making, this retro Metroidvania has a whip-smart Steam Next Fest demo that's as Castlevania as it gets
Hollow Knight: Silksong screenshot from the announcement trailer, showing the Knight battling an enemy in a gloomy environment.
Hollow Knight Silksong: Everything we know so far
Latest in PC Gaming
Let's Build a Dungeon
"They will cancel their subscription and your investors will have your head": This management sim about making the perfect MMO is so detailed it lets you play your own game
Hollow Knight
Day 1,251: Hollow Knight's strongest soldier has been fighting the boss version of Silksong star Hornet every day for over 3 years, and watching them master the Metroidvania in real time is truly amazing
The two characters in Split Fiction dressed in fantasy gear each with a dragon on their back
2025's first standout GOTY contenders, Monster Hunter Wilds, Kingdom Come Deliverance 2, and Split Fiction, are coming to GeForce Now
Monster Hunter Wilds beta and trailer screenshots
No one is safe from Monster Hunter Wilds' monstrous menus: BioWare lead says he forgot "how…interesting…the matchmaking and world sharing in these games were"
Until Dawn Remake developer “effectively closed” following an unannounced wave of layoffs hitting the company
Cooking in Monster Hunter Wilds
Changing your pants in Monster Hunter Wilds also changes your most important weapon: the little knife you use to carve beasts, with at least 25 different skins available
Latest in News
Alien Earth teaser
New Alien: Earth teaser introduces us to new cast members and the cutest little cat – and if a Xenomorph eats it, I will be furious
Three RTX 5070 gaming PCs on a purple background
I'm surprised to see some RTX 5070 gaming PCs under $2,000 - these are the three prebuilds I'd buy this week
Let's Build a Dungeon
"They will cancel their subscription and your investors will have your head": This management sim about making the perfect MMO is so detailed it lets you play your own game
Mark Ruffalo and Toni Collette in Mickey 17
Although the Mickey 17 cast were at first baffled by the unique way Parasite director Bong Joon Ho works, now they want it no other way
Hollow Knight
Day 1,251: Hollow Knight's strongest soldier has been fighting the boss version of Silksong star Hornet every day for over 3 years, and watching them master the Metroidvania in real time is truly amazing
Chris Pine and Michelle Rodriguez in Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves
The Monopoly movie from Margot Robbie's production company will be written by the Dungeons and Dragons movie directors