Analysts predict Switch 2 might struggle with attracting mainstream buyers for the same reason Wii U failed: "I can imagine 'normies' being a bit confused"

Nintendo Switch 2 in dock
(Image credit: Nintendo)

Nintendo's Switch 2 reveal felt like a lightning bolt delivered straight from Zeus himself for everyone except, well, most people. In fact, since the console – which fans have spent years clamoring for – looks so much like its predecessor, some analysts predict it'll have trouble appealing to a general audience.

"I can imagine 'normies' being a bit confused," gaming industry consultant Serkan Toto tells 12DOVE. "The device is bigger than the original Switch, but not comically large. The form factor, button layout, and overall design are very similar to Switch 1, so I can imagine issues arising when potential mainstream buyers look at the new device."

Even I, as someone whose job it is to care about the Switch 2, find myself observing its long black screen, petite Joy-Con controllers, and matte joysticks and thinking, wow… that looks just like the Nintendo Switch…

The Wii U – essentially a Wii that used a primitive Switch as a GamePad – faced similar prejudice when it debuted in 2012 and sold poorly. Casual gamers didn't understand what made the device a worthwhile replacement to the perfectly good Wii consoles they already owned to play golf in Koopa Park.

Others thought, as a younger 12DOVE put it in 2011, the console "might well be a pimp-daddy polygon-processing motherf*cker from the future right now, but if it gets superseded by new Microsoft and Sony consoles in two years, it'll suddenly stop being exciting as a pure gaming machine." You know?

Nintendo officially shut down the Wii U's online service last April. Maybe Nintendo, now being older and wiser, has learned its lesson. Its reveal trailer, at least, seems to make a point of distinguishing the Switch 2's otherwise indistinguishable features from the original Switch, showing off the console's extra USB-C port and demonstrating what seem to be mouse sensors with a magician's flourish.

And we can't forget all those hungry Nintendo fans who have wanted this for so long. Sameness is titillating to some people. So Circana gaming industry analyst Mat Piscatella thinks the Switch 2 will be a "massive success," and he tells us he predicts Nintendo will sell approximately 16 million Switch 2 consoles worldwide by the end of 2025.

Even so, "it looks to be a bigger, more powerful Switch," Piscatella says. "Exactly what people wanted and expected. But also, it looks to be primarily a bigger, more powerful Switch, which may not be enough to attract an audience outside of buyers of the original Switch." Well, you can never win everyone over.

Veteran analyst expects Switch 2 to be "a massive success," but doesn't see it matching the "outlier" that was the Switch 1: "It could happen, but it's not likely."

CATEGORIES
Ashley Bardhan
Senior Writer

Ashley is a Senior Writer at 12DOVE. She's been a staff writer at Kotaku and Inverse, too, and she's written freelance pieces about horror and women in games for sites like Rolling Stone, Vulture, IGN, and Polygon. When she's not covering gaming news, she's usually working on expanding her doll collection while watching Saw movies one through 11.

Read more
The Joy-Con connecting pins on the Switch 2
Veteran analyst expects Switch 2 to be "a massive success," but doesn't see it matching the "outlier" that was the Switch 1: "It could happen, but it's not likely"
The Steam Deck OLED side by side with a Switch 2's controller, separated by an orange line
Is the Switch 2 set up for success in a post-Steam Deck world?
A screenshot from the reveal trailer for the Nintendo Switch 2, showing the console playing a Mario Kart game.
If the Switch 2's potential matches its aesthetic glow-up, this might be the first time I buy a new console at launch
A screenshot from the reveal trailer for the Nintendo Switch 2, showing the console playing a Mario Kart game.
From what we've seen so far, the Nintendo Switch 2's closest relative could be the Game Boy Advance
Mario Kart running on Nintendo Switch 2
Nintendo Switch 2 will need big growth outside the US and Japan to do as well as Switch 1, says veteran analyst: "There have to be some surprises"
Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
After its supposedly accurate Switch 2 mock-up went viral, accessory maker says it "didn't expect this much media attention" because it thought all the information had already leaked
Latest in Nintendo Switch 2
Mario Super Sluggers
Nintendo history comes full circle as it puts the Switch 2 logo on the baseball team its late president Hiroshi Yamauchi bought 33 years ago
Nintendo Switch 2 next to TV with controller grip and JoyCons hovering
Weeks before the Switch 2 Direct, updated Nintendo patent shows AI upscaling technology that could give the next console more in common with the PS5 Pro than expected
Splatoon
New Nintendo patent implies veteran Splatoon developers are behind that mystery Minecraft-like game playtested last year
FGS Spring 2025
Everything announced at the Future Games Show Spring Showcase 2025
Nintendo Switch 2, dock and TV
Nintendo Switch 2 could cost $400-$500, say analysts, but it might launch with a Super Mario Odyssey follow-up and Metroid Prime 4
Nintendo Store NYC
After 20 years, a second Nintendo Store is set to open in the US this May
Latest in News
Lunar Remastered Collection
"Will today’s players still enjoy a game from 30 years ago?": JRPG icon Kei Shigema says he was thrilled to see Lunar getting a remaster even after all this time
Nick Offerman as Bill and Murray Bartlett as Frank in The Last of Us episode 3
The Last of Us season 2 showrunners tease a "gorgeous" episode akin to season 1’s Emmy-nominated Bill and Frank story: "Just you wait"
The Witcher 4 screenshot with Ciri using sword and sorcery to fight an ancient monster
CD Projekt boss says "cutting-edge single-player games" – you know, like The Witcher 4 and Cyberpunk 2 – will "continue to enjoy great popularity" despite industry shifts
Cyberpunk 2077
Despite releasing exactly zero new games, CD Projekt bagged $120 million in profit for 2024 – the Witcher and Cyberpunk studio's third-best result ever
Muse
Daredevil: Born Again midseason trailer teases Matt Murdock’s violent fight with Muse, including a gory scene straight from the comics
Batman looking over the city during Batman: Arkham City, one of the best PS3 games.
The PS2 Batman Begins game was considered such a "disaster" that Christopher Nolan turned down a Dark Knight-inspired game