Moonlight review

Why you can trust 12DOVE Our experts review games, movies and tech over countless hours, so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about our reviews policy.

Writer/director Brad Silberling knows death. His films to date - - 1995's kiddie ghost caper Casper and 1998's afterlife romancer City Of Angels - - both explored it in one form or another. Now comes Moonlight Mile, loosely based on a tragedy that struck close to home when Silberling's then-girlfriend, actress Rebecca Schaeffer, was murdered by an obsessed fan.

Silberling's channelled his grief into Joe Nast (Jake Gyllenhaal), a young man struggling to deal with his fiancée's murder in a restaurant shooting while living with the girl's parents, JoJo (Susan Sarandon) and Ben (Dustin Hoffman). Each deals with the loss in their own way: Ben has thrown himself into his work as a real estate agent, while JoJo reacts to the writer's block she's suffering with sarcasm and wit. Joe, though, is having a crisis of conscience - - does he tell the family that he and their daughter broke up on the day of the shooting? And while he's trying to decide if he's staying around, how can he be falling for local lass Bertie (Ellen Pompeo)?

The three leads all get their moments, with Sarandon provoking most of the bittersweet laughs, Hoffman digging deep to provide one of his best performances in recent years and Gyllenhaal enjoying several standout scenes. Okay, so there's nothing here to yet prove he can break away from his sleepy-eyed depressive routine, but his confrontation with a business client during dinner is so good and so funny, you'll be willing to let it go.

The script's downsides, on the other hand, are a little less easy to forgive, with Silberling dipping his quill in the schmaltz-pot a little too regularly. The pat resolutions are beneath actors of this ability - the cast of Crossroads could handle them without any trouble - and there's a court scene that's pure Hollywood emoto-cheese.

But for all its faults, Moonlight Mile manages to be an involving, well-observed drama. Give it a go.

It may roll around in Tinseltown syrup towards the end, but Moonlight Mile boasts a great cast at the top of their games. As an added bonus, it also has one of the best soundtracks of the year.

The Total Film team are made up of the finest minds in all of film journalism. They are: Editor Jane Crowther, Deputy Editor Matt Maytum, Reviews Ed Matthew Leyland, News Editor Jordan Farley, and Online Editor Emily Murray. Expect exclusive news, reviews, features, and more from the team behind the smarter movie magazine. 

Latest in Action Movies
The cast of Thunderbolts
Marvel fans are revealing who they'd like to see added to the Thunderbolts lineup, from Moon Knight to a major Hulk villain
Black Widow
Scarlett Johansson doubles down on never coming back as Black Widow: “Natasha is dead. She is dead. She’s dead. Okay?"
Lady Gaga as Harley Quinn on set of Joker 2
Lady Gaga jokingly celebrates Joker 2 reception and Razzie nominations: "Joke's on them. I love winning things"
Jack Quaid in Novocaine
The Boys star Jack Quaid's commitment to the bit is unmatched as his latest marketing stunt for upcoming action movie Novocaine goes viral
Julian McMahon as Doctor Doom in 2005's Fantastic Four
The Doctor Doom actor from 2005's Fantastic Four thinks Robert Downey Jr.'s take on the role in the next Avengers movies will be "pretty extraordinary": "I love watching his work"
Jason Momoa as Arthur Curry in Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom
James Gunn reveals Jason Momoa text him about Lobo the day he was announced as DC Studios co-head
Latest in Reviews
Lenovo Legion Go S with FlyKnight gameplay on screen featuring player character holding bow and arrow with enemy ant in backdrop.
Lenovo Legion Go S Windows 11 review: “my heart aches for this mixed up handheld”
Talisman 5th Edition game components
Talisman 5th Edition review: "The characterful imperfections of the original game remain clear to see "
WWE 2K25
WWE 2K25 review: "A colossal package even if you never go anywhere near Virtual Currency"
Altered: Trial by Frost booster box and packs on a playmat
Altered: Trial by Frost review - "Satisfying enough to offer highly varied gameplay"
Three SteelSeries QcK Performance mouse pads on a wooden desk
I didn't expect to prefer a coarser mouse pad, but SteelSeries' new QcK Performance range has changed my mind
Boro and Alta sit on a bench together in Wanderstop
Wanderstop review: "Exalting the transformative power of tea"