Great concepts, bad games
Taking a look at games that had brilliant ideas, but just didn't hold their own in the gameplay department
It's a sad truth indeed that some terrible games in the past have actually had seriously solid ideas. A good idea does not automatically mean a good game, as demonstrated countless times by an industry that, more often than not, produces the very best products when creativity is all but bankrupt. A real shame, but that's the truth of the matter.
Budget constraints, technological problems, or a simple case of being too ambitious for one's own good can all have an effect on a title, meaning that no matter how deep your narrative, unique your gimmicks, or breathtaking your vision, concept alone cannot save a game. With that wretched fact in mind, let's take a look at some examples of absolutely killer concepts that went wrong somewhere along the line and ended up as bad videogames.
Sign up to the 12DOVE Newsletter
Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5665f/5665fc1c72f55873460a04543a3084314e97ce26" alt="A screenshot shows the pixel art characters of Angeline Era floating through stars."
The devs of a legendary indie Zelda-like have a new retro action game with "bumpslash" combat, and its Steam Next Fest demo is a gem: "Fans of Ys, take note!"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c97b4/c97b4cc5f298a4c5531922840000062b23c699a4" alt="Beyond the Ice Palace 2 screenshots showing whip attacks"
And you thought Hollow Knight: Silksong is late – 37 years in the making, this retro Metroidvania has a whip-smart Steam Next Fest demo that's as Castlevania as it gets