12DOVE Verdict
It’s great to see a gritty girl-gang story that’s not a fingerwagging cautionary tale, or a grrrlpower fantasy. Sciamma finishes her coming-of-age trilogy on a high note.
Why you can trust 12DOVE
She’s the leader of the pack...
French arthouse darling Céline Sciamma really hits the mark with this tender, spirited story of a stifled teen rebelling in a tough girl gang on a Parisian sink estate. As in the atmospheric Waterlilies and touching Tomboy, Sciamma captures the energy, stern loyalties and harsh rivalries of young girls with a sharp and sympathetic eye.
What’s fresh here is how she gets right under the skin of restless 15 year old Marieme (a fine-textured turn from first-time actress Karidja Touré). Desperate to escape her dead-end schooling and slap-happy elder brother, she reinvents herself as the knife-toting Vic in a mouthy quartet of shoplifting, lunch-money-looting bad girls.
There’s an echo of Andrea Arnold’s Fish Tank in these oppressed tower-block teens, juggling big desires and limited options, but rather than gloomy social realism the film finds moody beauty in the girls’ windblown concrete hangouts.
Sciamma shapes her story with an artful style that’s light on dialogue and long on atmosphere. Employing drawn-out, immersive scenes and stylised visuals, she sums up the sheer exhilaration of teenage kicks in a stunning sequence where the girls party giddily to Rihanna’s ‘Diamonds’.
Street fights and family fisticuffs have in-your-face intensity as does Touré’s expressive playing, seguing seamlessly from dutiful daughter to queen bitch, from trembling first love to freedom-seeking gender-bender.
Too bad, then, that the film’s careful immersion and setting is marred late on by bumpy plotting, lurching unexpectedly from dance-offs to drug-dealing, as Marieme challenges Assa Sylla’s charismatic ringleader, Lady, for the top spot. When a film has this kind of emotional intensity, there’s no need for melodrama.
More info
Theatrical release | 8 May 2015 |
Director | Cline Sciamma |
Starring | "Karidja Tour","Assa Sylla","Lindsay Karamoh","Maritou Tour" |
Kate is a freelance film journalist and critic. Her bylines have appeared online and in print for GamesRadar, Total Film, the BFI, Sight & Sounds, and WithGuitars.com.
There's a new Mummy movie on the way from the director of Evil Dead Rise and I just want to know if Blumhouse has called Brendan Fraser yet
Marvel Rivals made Jeff the Land Shark so stinkin' adorable that the MCU is bringing him on as an official hero: "We're all Jeff fans around here. Man is he fun to play"
Doctor Who star Ncuti Gatwa reflects on the one year anniversary of his debut as the Doctor admitting "I didn't quite realize the magnitude of what I was taking on"