Astro Bot devs ditched an "expansive" open-world game because a "two-course meal" beats eating "a lot of food at a buffet"

Astro Bot
(Image credit: Sony)

Astro Bot developer Team Asobi initially considered making the hit platformer an open-world game early in development but decided against it in favor of something more focused.

Speaking to the BBC, director Nicolas Doucet reveals that Team Asobi entertained the idea of an open-world game early in development but felt a more segmented, level-based approach was best for the project.

"It's also a very good string to add to a bow," Doucet says. "Game production can be very complex with a lot of things that go well and a lot of things that don't go well when you have to pivot all the time and find the best way forward. And it's really good to have a modular game in which you can swap things around – you can even drop a piece, replace it with something else."

Doucet's comments follow a rather tasty metaphor about turning away from a game that offers 40 hours in an expansive world in favor of 12 to 15 in a tightly polished game.

“You can eat a lot of food at a buffet, or you could just go for that two-course meal," he says. "That's really going to be small but just the right amount, but this one is going to be memorable. So, in fact, you could say that you have more for your money with the buffet, but what's the last memory you take away with you?"

Doucet goes on to say it's likely related to being bloated after eating too much, which is something I and—I imagine—plenty of you might relate to.

All in all, Doucet's hunger-inspiring comments speak to a design philosophy of creating something short and sweet to avoid depth for the sake of it. Doucet has spoken before about shooting for "12 to 15 hours of condensed fun" over 40 hours with bloat "you feel like skipping." Given the slew of struggling live-service games we've seen over the years and Astro Bot's own glowing reviews, it's hard to argue.

We gave the platformer a perfect score in our own Astro Bot review, in fact. We said: "Astro Bot doesn't just deliver on the promise and potential displayed in PS5 pack-in demo Astro's Playroom, but soars above and beyond to serve up a near-perfect platformer to rival – and possibly surpass – the best of Super Mario's Mushroom Kingdom romps."

Fancy a feast? Here's how to unlock all Astro Bot collectibles, including Bots, Puzzle Pieces, and Warps. 

Deputy News Editor

Iain joins the GamesRadar team as Deputy News Editor following stints at PCGamesN and PocketGamer.Biz, with some freelance for Kotaku UK, RockPaperShotgun, and VG24/7 thrown in for good measure. When not helping Ali run the news team, he can be found digging into communities for stories – the sillier the better. When he isn’t pillaging the depths of Final Fantasy 14 for a swanky new hat, you’ll find him amassing an army of Pokemon plushies.

Read more
Astro Bot dressed as God of War's Kratos
Team Asobi's gigantic 2024 proves it's time to free Astro Bot from PlayStation's past
A little bot in a Gex costume adorably waving his arms as he watches TV with a bucket of popcorn on his lap. I hope nobody knocks it over
Former Nintendo boss says "I have to admit it," Astro Bot "almost outdid Nintendo at its own game"
Astro Bot
PlayStation devs on Astro Bot share their GOTY acceptance with Nintendo, the king of platformers: "We want to pay tribute to them tonight"
How long is Astro Bot?
How long is Astro Bot?
Astro Bot
Astro Bot guide for budding space adventurers
A Helldivers-inspired bot in Astro Bot placing a flag into the ground.
After Helldivers 2 and Astro Bot success, live service and family games are genres PlayStation wants to "expand in the future"
Latest in Platformer
Limbo
"You can't rewrite the past just because of a bad breakup": Legendary indie devs' feud is going public
Image of the Nintendo Switch box art for Princess Peach Showtime, Ys X Nordics, Unicorn Overlord and Super Mario Jamboree on a GamesRadar pink background.
Mario Day's colossal savings on these games is enough to make me forget about the Switch 2 for now
Earthblade trailer screenshot
Celeste composer releases soundtrack from canceled Metroidvania game Earthblade, and it's a tearjerker mash-up of classic anime soundtracks and synth: "We'll never get a chance to tell that story in game form"
Donkey Kong 94
Forget Pokemon Red and Blue, Nintendo's finally brought the secret best Game Boy game to Switch: an expanded version of Donkey Kong with 2425% more levels
Sonic Unleashed Recompiled
Sonic fans are leading the charge on a new preservation tool that can help give any Xbox 360 game a native PC port
Rascal celebrates completing Buccaneer's Beach in Rollin' Rascal
My dream Sonic game is finally real and it even has online multiplayer, except it's actually this "high-speed" 3D platformer with a glorious demo in Steam Next Fest
Latest in News
World of Warcraft
World of Warcraft guild cheats its way to winning Race for World First, gets caught, banned, then reverses its name and does it all over again
A AMD Ryzen 7 8700G being put into it's socket by a reviewer
AMD's new Ryzen 9 X3D processors launch today, here's the stock I've found so far
GTA 3 Mobile screenshot showing claude running away from police near a casino
The fan-made Dreamcast version of GTA 3 is looking way better in the latest look, introducing tech that "would’ve previously been a slideshow"
Scarlett Johansson in Jurassic World Rebirth
Jurassic World Rebirth studio asked Scarlett Johansson to join Instagram, but she refused: "The film will do fine"
Deltarune
Undertale creator Toby Fox's tomfoolery leaves Deltarune testers thinking an intentional nerf was actually a bug after they "independently" discovered it
Pokemon Go player trying to catch a Croagunk
Pokemon Go developer Niantic is being bought for $3.5 billion, CEO says it'll help its games be "'forever games' that will endure for future generations"