The Silent Hill 2 Remake director has pitched a Lord of the Rings horror game, and suddenly I'm hunched over growling 'my precious' at the thought of it

Adar in The Rings of Power season 2 episode 7
(Image credit: Prime Video)

Silent Hill 2 Remake director Mateusz Lenart once pitched a Lord of the Rings horror game, and now I feel utterly lost in a world without one.

First spotted by The Gamer, Lenart appeared in a recent episode of the Bonfire Conversations podcast (timestamped here) and said his dream project is a medieval horror RPG. He also expressed his passion for fantasy and Lord of the Rings author J.R.R. Tolkien in particular, which prompted the interviewer to say a Lord of the Rings horror game would be "cool."

Lenart agreed, saying, "don't think I didn't pitch my ideas for one."

I suppose now's as good a time as ever to throw my hat into the ring and also say I emphatically agree with this. The Lord of the Rings franchise is ripe with potential for horror. Remember the scene in Fellowship of the Ring where Frodo and the hobbits are hiding from the Nazgûl? It's legitimately terrifying! And that's just one example. The jump scare when Bilbo spazzes out after Frodo shows him the ring? The flippin' birthing of the orcs? Lord of the Rings is low-key a horror IP already!

Anyway, sadly Lenart gave no indication that he's actually working on a Lord of the Rings horror game, but he definitely made it pretty clear he's game for one if Bloober Team ever gave him the budget. That said, I'd be surprised if Embracer Group ever licensed out the rights again after a certain 2023 Lord of the Rings game that wasn't so, uh, precious.

Silent Hill 2 Remake finally put Bloober Team on the map for horror fans, but in 2025 Cronos: The New Dawn will decide whether it stays there.

Jordan Gerblick

After scoring a degree in English from ASU, I worked as a copy editor while freelancing for places like SFX Magazine, Screen Rant, Game Revolution, and MMORPG on the side. Now, as GamesRadar's west coast Staff Writer, I'm responsible for managing the site's western regional executive branch, AKA my apartment, and writing about whatever horror game I'm too afraid to finish.

Read more
Silent Hill 2 remake
As "the success of Silent Hill 2 speaks for itself," Bloober announces its continued partnership with Konami and a "truly special" new joint project
Silent Hill 2
Silent Hill 2 Remake finally put Bloober Team on the map for horror fans, but in 2025 Cronos: The New Dawn will decide whether it stays there
Anya Taylor-Joy and Miles Teller as Drasa and Levi in The Gorge
Sinister director says his new horror film The Gorge is partly inspired by Silent Hill and Until Dawn: "I love those games"
David Bowie in Labyrinth 1986
Nosferatu director Robert Eggers is making a sequel to one of my favorite childhood movies Labyrinth – and I have the perfect nightmarish storyline in mind
Sean Connery and Christopher Lambert on a beach in Highlander
After re-watching the Highlander TV show and movies, I started imagining what a modern-day game adaptation could look like - and now I want it
Concept art from Cronos: The New Dawn shows a fleshy creature with two heads and many arms.
Bloober's new sci-fi horror game looks like Silent Hill 2 meets Alien, the retrofuturistic gorefest I've always dreamed of
Latest in Horror
The Sinking City 2
After a years-long battle with its publisher, Ukraine-based studio reveals first gameplay footage of survival horror sequel The Sinking City 2, launches Kickstarter, and hits $100,000 goal in hours
Until Dawn Remake developer “effectively closed” following an unannounced wave of layoffs hitting the company
A scary emoji shown in horror game REPO.
Is REPO coming to consoles?
The Eye in horror game Repo.
All monsters in REPO and how to beat them
A cart being driven to the extraction point in horror game REPO.
How to revive players in REPO
Three players in a REPO game.
How many people can play REPO?
Latest in News
a titanium watch with grey and orange features on the arms and face
You can look like Solid Snake with this Death Stranding 2 watch, but it'll cost you over $1,500
Monster Hunter Wilds trailer screenshot showing a young woman with long blonde hair tied back into a ponytail smiling slightly, pumping her left fist in the air
Monster Hunter Wilds' Gemma actor requests "tips for beginners" from fans of Capcom's action RPG as it's the "first MH game that I've ever played"
Doom: The Dark Ages screenshot
Doom director claims The Dark Ages can be beaten without using a gun, but "the game's not necessarily built to do that"
Giancarlo Esposito in The Electric State
The Electric State may be the Russo brothers' most challenging VFX project yet, but stars Stanley Tucci and Giancarlo Esposito say it's one of the easiest films they’ve ever done
The Last of Us season 2 trailer shows spores
The Last of Us season 2 is bringing in one of the biggest game omissions from season 1 – and the showrunners say it's for a "good reason"
Chris Cocks with a transformer grimmacing behind him
Hasbro CEO, D&D DM, and self-professed "AI bull" Chris Cocks says AI is "supercharging fandom" which is "just net good for the brand"