First reactions to Captain America: Brave New World compare the Marvel movie to Winter Soldier, but point out some major issues

Captain America: Brave New World
(Image credit: Marvel Studios)

The first reactions to Captain America: Brave New World have dropped, and they're pretty mixed on the Marvel Phase 5 movie. Some have been calling it a return to form for the MCU, while others say the cast deserve better.

12DOVE's Lauren Milici tweeted: "I rly liked #CaptainAmericaBraveNewWorld not just bc i think we should put Danny Ramirez in everything but bc it wasn’t an over-the-top jaunt packed w/ cameos - it’s a simple heartwarming tale about good guys vs bad guys which imo is, at its core, what a Marvel movie should be."

Critic Laura Sirikul wrote: "#CaptainAmericaBraveNewWorld  proves that Sam Wilson can lead a #CaptainAmerica  movie. The writing & acting is very strong as a political thriller mixed with superhero elements. While not perfect, it was very engaging & entertaining."

Presenter Brandon Davis was also a fan, tweeting: "#CaptainAmericaBraveNewWorld is flat out good. It feels like an MCU return to form, progressing the overall story with a thrilling tale of its own. It’s pretty nonstop! The villain feels a bit secondary. Solid action. Harrison Ford is ALL IN. Mackie really claims the mantle."

Critic Scott Menzel writes: "Captain America: Brave New World is a game-changer for Phase 5 of the MCU. Mackie soars past the role of Falcon cementing himself as the new Captain America. Ford puts his signature grunting and crankiness to great use as Thaddeus Ross and Red Hulk. Brave New World is like Falcon and The Winter Solider but bigger and better because of the scope and scale of this big screen adventure."

Others were not as convinced, with freelance critic Cody Dericks writing: "Good news! If you’ve been missing the boring action and ugly visuals of post-Endgame MCU, then CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD is for you. Totally disposable, with inadvertent comedic moments and absolutely hollow political commentary…at least Harrison Ford is dialed-in."

Nerdist's Dan Casey agreed, tweeting: "CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD was unfortunately pretty disappointing. It’s a lumbering hodgepodge of MCU plot devices of Christmas past that collapses under the strain of its reshoots. It’s not a total wash, but Anthony Mackie in particular deserved better."

Check out some more below.

Captain America 4 sees Anthony Mackie fully take on the superhero mantle for the first time after Steve Rogers gave him the shield in Avengers: Endgame. The movie sees Sam Wilson caught in the center of an international incident after Thaddeus Ross (Harrison Ford) is elected as the president of the United States.

Based on the trailers so far, it seems pretty likely this is going to be linked to the introduction of Adamantium to the MCU. As well as Ford and Mackie, the movie also stars Danny Ramirez as the new Falcon, Giancarlo Esposito as Sidewinder, and brings back Tim Blake Nelson as The Leader.

Speaking to 12DOVE, Mackie said he was "excited as hell" to finally be playing Captain America on the big screen. "You have to think about how much work and how much time went into this," he explained. "They told me I was gonna be Captain America five years ago. So I've just been biding my time waiting for this moment. But the excitement of it comes with the idea of, Marvel gave me the best cast, they gave me the best script, they gave me the best crew, they gave me the best director to make the best movie we could make. And I'm just really proud of it."

Captain America: Brave New World arrives in theaters on February 14. For more on the MCU, check out our guides to all the upcoming Marvel movies and shows on the way as well as our guide to watching the Marvel movies in order.

Fay Watson
Deputy Entertainment Editor

I’m the Deputy Entertainment Editor here at 12DOVE, covering TV and film for the Total Film and SFX sections online. I previously worked as a Senior Showbiz Reporter and SEO TV reporter at Express Online for three years. I've also written for The Resident magazines and Amateur Photographer, before specializing in entertainment.

Read more
Danny Ramirez and Anthony Mackie in Captain America: Brave New World
Captain America: Brave New World review: "Anthony Mackie's Cap earns his Stars and Stripes in this uneven, un-MCU thriller"
Anthony Mackie in Captain America: Brave New World
Captain America: Brave New World release date, cast, trailer, and more Marvel news
Captain America: Brave New World
Marvel fans are loving Captain America: Brave New World way more than critics as very divisive Rotten Tomatoes score emerges
Harrison Ford as Red Hulk in Captain America: Brave New World
Despite one of the MCU's lowest Rotten Tomatoes scores, Captain America: Brave New World has a massive opening weekend, already making back its reported production budget
Captain America: Brave New World trailer
New Captain America: Brave New World teaser gives us our best look yet at Danny Ramirez's Falcon and has everyone making the same joke
Harrison Ford as Red Hulk in Captain America: Brave New World
Captain America: Brave New World ends a surprising 17-year Marvel streak with its no-nonsense opening
Latest in Marvel Movies
Avengers: Endgame
The Russo brothers reveal that Marvel has an ingenious way of working out which actors they can use for upcoming Avengers movies
Jenna Ortega as Wednesday Addams dancing during the Netflix series, Wednesday.
Wednesday star Jenna Ortega denies rumors of big Marvel role after her disappointing MCU debut 12 years ago: “I count that and I move on”
Vincent D'Onofrio as Wilson Fisk in Daredevil: Born Again
Daredevil: Born Again star Vincent D'Onofrio swiftly shoots down reports of his involvement in Spider-Man 4
Robert Downey Jr announces his Doctor Doom casting at San Diego Comic-Con 2024
The Russo brothers finally debunk that Avengers: Doomsday concept art leak: "Nothing spoiling in there"
Gemma Chan in Eternals
Eternals star Gemma Chan is hopeful she'll return to the MCU someday: "There's unfinished business there"
Sadie Sink as Max Mayfield in Stranger Things 4
Stranger Things star Sadie Sink joins Spider-Man 4 and fans are already theorizing she might be X-Men’s Jean Grey
Latest in News
Avengers: Endgame
The Russo brothers reveal that Marvel has an ingenious way of working out which actors they can use for upcoming Avengers movies
Jenna Ortega as Wednesday Addams dancing during the Netflix series, Wednesday.
Wednesday star Jenna Ortega denies rumors of big Marvel role after her disappointing MCU debut 12 years ago: “I count that and I move on”
Silent Hill f key art showing the main character holding a pipe
Silent Hill f trailer suggests Konami’s newest nightmare will bring back an iconic weapon central to every game in the franchise
Percy Jackson and the Olympians
Percy Jackson series gets unusually early renewal for season 3 before upcoming season 2 even airs
Silent Hill f
"What if we […] make it 100% Japanese?": Silent Hill f producer worried Konami's horror series was "starting to feel too westernized"
Psyduck looking stressed next to Misty
Pokemon streamer builds a controller so bad that it takes them a full 80 minutes to walk to FireRed's first city