Captain America: Brave New World review: "Anthony Mackie's Cap earns his Stars and Stripes in this uneven, un-MCU thriller"

Danny Ramirez and Anthony Mackie in Captain America: Brave New World
(Image: © Disney/Marvel)

12DOVE Verdict

Anthony Mackie's Captain America earns his Stars and Stripes in this uneven, un-MCU thriller. Sam Wilson and an always-excellent Harrison Ford drag Brave New World into unfamiliar narrative territory before it eventually succumbs to familiar Marvel failings

Pros

  • +

    Anthony Mackie's assured lead performance

  • +

    A compelling conspiracy drives the plot

  • +

    Harrison Ford understands the assignment

Cons

  • -

    A lackluster final act

  • -

    Red Hulk's big action sequence slightly disappoints

Why you can trust 12DOVE Our experts review games, movies and tech over countless hours, so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about our reviews policy.

Captain America: Brave New World wastes little time in getting its point across. Gone is the usual Marvel Studios opening fanfare and, in its place, a black-and-white logo that hints at a no-nonsense, back-to-basics thriller that's intent on reining the MCU in after a Phase filled with multiverse meddling and gratuitous cameos.

While the fourth Captain America movie doesn't quite make good on its bountiful potential, it does finally establish Anthony Mackie's Sam Wilson as an Avengers-leader-in-waiting. After all, it's been six long years since an elderly Steve Rogers (Chris Evans) passed the torch in Avengers: Endgame.

Disney Plus series The Falcon and The Winter Soldier showed early promise but, otherwise, the character (and Mackie) has been waiting in the wings for a chance to wield the shield and prove himself full time on the big screen. It's an opportunity he grabs here with both hands.

Zipping about the movie with a cocksure confidence only reserved for the cream of Earth's Mightiest Heroes, Mackie's Sam Wilson soon finds himself perched on top of a political powder keg as newly installed President Ross (Harrison Ford) makes a power play amid the discovery of Adamantium, the world's most versatile material, on the island formed out of the dead Celestial Tiamut (Eternals fans, this is your moment).

After the Fox-filled excesses of Deadpool and Wolverine, this refreshingly straightforward actioner once again proves the biggest strength of the MCU is in its malleability

"The threats we face show no sign of slowing down," Ford's Ross growls in the opening act, kickstarting an opening hour laced with all the hallmarks of a great thriller: assassination attempts, paranoia, and a chase for the mastermind led by Sam and his partner-in-stopping-crime Joaquin Torres, AKA The Falcon (Danny Ramirez).

Bolstered with a Wakanda-enhanced suit, Sam sets about untangling an increasingly knotty situation, one that brings Giancarlo Esposito's Serpent Society leader Sidewinder, Shira Haas' capable government agent Ruth, Carl Lumbly's returning Super Soldier Isaiah Bradley, and Tim Blake Nelson's The Leader into the fray.

Follow The Leader

Anthony Mackie as Captain America in Brave New World

(Image credit: Marvel Studios)

Of Brave New World's heaving ensemble of villains and wildcards, it's Esposito's Sidewinder that is emblematic of both its greatest strengths and familiar MCU weaknesses. The character is smartly deployed throughout the film and makes the most out of director Julius Onah's adept control over the suitably weighty action, while his ability to disrupt and crash into proceedings in unexpected fashion means the audience is always kept on its toes.

Still, Sidewinder's erratic presence appears to be the product of being stitched together through reshoots and additional photography, with his actions here only acting as an hors d'oeuvres before, presumably, he takes center stage in another Marvel project in several years once all momentum is drained from the character. Esposito could have easily been the focus in a grounded project such as this, but ultimately feels like it's making the best of a bad – and possibly Frankensteined in the editing booth – situation.

FAST FACTS

Release date: February 14, 2025
Available: In theaters
Director: Julius Onah
Runtime: 1hr 58 minutes

Most intriguingly for MCU diehards is the appearance of Tim Blake Nelson's Samuel Sterns/The Leader. Formerly a side concern in 2008's The Incredible Hulk, Captain America: Brave New World appears to relish in making Marvel's most forgotten – and largely forgettable – entry relevant again.

While Sterns only ever operates on the fringes, his cerebral, hands-off approach at least elevates Sam's Cap from a whipsmart, wisecracking hero into one that can sniff out clues, see through deception, and even be a little nasty in the field when the situation calls for it. It's a compelling foil for Sam to bounce off, despite their chalk-and-cheese dynamic never quite sparking in the vein of great villains from Captain America's cinematic past.

That, of course, works in tandem with Ford's 'Thunderbolt' Ross (here recast after the death of previous actor William Hurt). In truth, Ford's inclusion raises the magnetic presence that, Mackie aside, Brave New World so desperately requires. Ford is fantastic here as an irascible President under pressure, with the threat of the Red Hulk also looming large throughout Brave New World's slightly-dragging two-hour runtime. Arguably, Ford brings the sort of star power the MCU has been lacking since Robert Downey Jr.'s Tony Stark snapped off this mortal coil (and perhaps speaks to his surprise Doctor Doom comeback in next year's Avengers: Doomsday).

A thriller of two halves

Harrison Ford as Red Hulk in Captain America: Brave New World

(Image credit: Marvel Studios)

Despite the groundwork laid by the new Marvel movie's opening act-and-a-half, the taut, drum-tight plotting eventually comes unstuck. As the conspiracy unravels so, too, does Brave New World. What begins as a substantial detour from typical MCU fare rapidly turns into The Winter Soldier-lite in the back half, a litany of action sequences on auto-pilot and half-baked monologues about world-saving philosophies. Even the much-touted Red Hulk vs. Captain America clash doesn't quite live up to its heavyweight billing, despite a Serum-less Captain America that can be bruised and beaten frequently nudging Brave New World into intriguing narrative territory.

Yet, you can't help but applaud the effort. After the Fox-filled excesses of Deadpool and Wolverine, this refreshingly straightforward actioner once again proves the biggest strength of the MCU is in its malleability. A Brave New World, then? Not quite. But it's a step in the right direction.


Captain America: Brave New World releases in theaters worldwide on February 14. For more on the MCU, check out our guide to all the upcoming Marvel movies and shows on the way, as well as our guide to watching the Marvel movies in order.

Bradley Russell

I'm the Senior Entertainment Writer here at 12DOVE, focusing on news, features, and interviews with some of the biggest names in film and TV. On-site, you'll find me marveling at Marvel and providing analysis and room temperature takes on the newest films, Star Wars and, of course, anime. Outside of GR, I love getting lost in a good 100-hour JRPG, Warzone, and kicking back on the (virtual) field with Football Manager. My work has also been featured in OPM, FourFourTwo, and Game Revolution.

Read more
Captain America: Brave New World
First reactions to Captain America: Brave New World compare the Marvel movie to Winter Soldier, but point out some major issues
Anthony Mackie in Captain America: Brave New World
Captain America: Brave New World release date, cast, trailer, and more Marvel news
Harrison Ford as Red Hulk in Captain America: Brave New World
Captain America: Brave New World ends a surprising 17-year Marvel streak with its no-nonsense opening
Captain America: Brave New World
Marvel fans are loving Captain America: Brave New World way more than critics as very divisive Rotten Tomatoes score emerges
Anthony Mackie in Captain America: Brave New World
After a 4 year absence, Captain America: Brave New World proves Anthony Mackie's Sam Wilson deserves to be the MCU's figurehead in Avengers 5 and beyond
Harrison Ford as Red Hulk in Captain America: Brave New World
Despite one of the MCU's lowest Rotten Tomatoes scores, Captain America: Brave New World has a massive opening weekend, already making back its reported production budget
Latest in Marvel Movies
Doctor Doom in Marvel Comics
The Russo brothers say Avengers: Doomsday and Secret Wars will draw inspiration from multiple comics – which explains how Doctor Doom might fit into the story
The cast of Thunderbolts
Marvel fans are revealing who they'd like to see added to the Thunderbolts lineup, from Moon Knight to a major Hulk villain
Black Widow
Scarlett Johansson doubles down on never coming back as Black Widow: “Natasha is dead. She is dead. She’s dead. Okay?"
Julian McMahon as Doctor Doom in 2005's Fantastic Four
The Doctor Doom actor from 2005's Fantastic Four thinks Robert Downey Jr.'s take on the role in the next Avengers movies will be "pretty extraordinary": "I love watching his work"
Anthony Mackie in Captain America: Brave New World
Brave New World box office crosses milestone for Captain America movies, even though it still might not break even
Black Widow post-credits
Avengers Tower will have a new name in Thunderbolts, and the movie's director says it's "a symbol of things taking a darker turn"
Latest in Reviews
Lenovo Legion Go S with FlyKnight gameplay on screen featuring player character holding bow and arrow with enemy ant in backdrop.
Lenovo Legion Go S Windows 11 review: “my heart aches for this mixed up handheld”
Talisman 5th Edition game components
Talisman 5th Edition review: "The characterful imperfections of the original game remain clear to see "
WWE 2K25
WWE 2K25 review: "A colossal package even if you never go anywhere near Virtual Currency"
Altered: Trial by Frost booster box and packs on a playmat
Altered: Trial by Frost review - "Satisfying enough to offer highly varied gameplay"
Three SteelSeries QcK Performance mouse pads on a wooden desk
I didn't expect to prefer a coarser mouse pad, but SteelSeries' new QcK Performance range has changed my mind
Boro and Alta sit on a bench together in Wanderstop
Wanderstop review: "Exalting the transformative power of tea"