The Penguin showrunner debunks popular fan theory: "Well, I can say he's not the Scarecrow"

The Penguin episode 8 (2024)
(Image credit: HBO/SKY)

The Penguin showrunner Lauren LeFranc has shut down a popular fan theory about the show.

Eagle-eyed fans spotted some suspicious items in Julian Rush's office during The Penguin episode 4, with what looks to be a syringe glove and a mask on show. That led to speculation that the psychiatrist is actually Jonathan Crane, AKA The Scarecrow – a Batman villain who hasn't been seen in a live-action movie since the Christopher Nolan films.

But, as it turns out, Rush isn't the villain after all. "Well, I can say he's not the Scarecrow," LeFranc told Screen Rant.

It's a pretty convincing theory, but, unless LeFranc is trying to trick us, we'll accept the debunk.

Next up for the Reeves-verse is The Batman 2, which was recently delayed to 2027. At the Golden Globes, Reeves explained the reason for the delay to The Hollywood Reporter: "Because we're still finishing the script, and there's been so many things going on. Next year is very much about getting into production, and getting the movie going, and we're very excited about it."

If you're wondering why Batman never intervened in The Penguin, Reeves has explained that before, too. "This was a time of great turmoil in the city, it's literally the week after what happened," he said, referring to Riddler's flood from the first movie. "Much of the city is in desperation, so police can't get everywhere, there's crime everywhere, it's a very, very dangerous time.

"[Batman's] out there trying to grapple with the aftermath of everything that happened, which to some degree he blames himself for," he added.

While you wait for the next Batman movie, check out our guide to all the upcoming movies of the year to fill out your watchlist.

TOPICS
CATEGORIES
Molly Edwards
Senior Entertainment Writer

I'm a Senior Entertainment Writer here at 12DOVE, covering all things film and TV for the site's Total Film and SFX sections. I previously worked on the Disney magazines team at Immediate Media, and also wrote on the CBeebies, MEGA!, and Star Wars Galaxy titles after graduating with a BA in English. 

Read more
The Penguin episode 8 (2024)
The Penguin season 2 looks promising, as Matt Reeves reveals he's talking to the showrunner about continuing the DC show
The Penguin
Colin Farrell says he is "open to" doing The Penguin season 2, but has "no deep desire" to return
The Batman
The Batman 2 director teases "completely different" sequel, as he promises the movie's main villain will surprise DC fans
Colin Farrell in The Penguin
James Gunn tries to clear up which projects are DC Studios, but it's still pretty confusing
Robert Pattinson in The Batman
Matt Reeves explains why The Batman 2 is delayed to 2027, but says they still want to film this year
Matt Hagen
DC Studios boss says Batman villain Clayface is "even more terrifying" than Penguin and Joker
Latest in DC TV Shows
Alan Ritchson as Jack Reacher in Reacher season 3
Reacher star Alan Ritchson wants to play Batman so bad, he says "you wouldn't even have to pay me"
A screenshot of the title card for the upcoming DC show, Starfire.
James Gunn confirms that the Starfire animated TV show will be Elseworlds like Batman and Joker
Aaron Pierre as John Stewart and Kyle Chandler as Hal Jordan in Lanterns
The first look at Aaron Pierre and Kyle Chandler's Green Lantern TV series is here – and DC fans are losing it over Hal Jordan's ring
The Penguin
Colin Farrell says he is "open to" doing The Penguin season 2, but has "no deep desire" to return
Creature Commandos
DC is fast-tracking Creature Commandos season 2 after overwhelmingly positive reaction to season 1
John Cena as Peacemaker in Peacemaker season 1
Peacemaker season 2: Everything we know so far about James Gunn's returning DC series
Latest in News
a titanium watch with grey and orange features on the arms and face
You can look like Solid Snake with this Death Stranding 2 watch, but it'll cost you over $1,500
Daniel Craig in No Time to Die
James Bond will reportedly remain male and British under new Amazon management, as Pierce Brosnan says it's "a given" that the next actor must not be American
Monster Hunter Wilds trailer screenshot showing a young woman with long blonde hair tied back into a ponytail smiling slightly, pumping her left fist in the air
Monster Hunter Wilds' Gemma actor requests "tips for beginners" from fans of Capcom's action RPG as it's the "first MH game that I've ever played"
Doom: The Dark Ages screenshot
Doom director claims The Dark Ages can be beaten without using a gun, but "the game's not necessarily built to do that"
Giancarlo Esposito in The Electric State
The Electric State may be the Russo brothers' most challenging VFX project yet, but stars Stanley Tucci and Giancarlo Esposito say it's one of the easiest films they’ve ever done
The Last of Us season 2 trailer shows spores
The Last of Us season 2 is bringing in one of the biggest game omissions from season 1 – and the showrunners say it's for a "good reason"