Why you can trust 12DOVE Our experts review games, movies and tech over countless hours, so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about our reviews policy.
Anyone expecting Stephen Baxter to give us the 2001: A Space Odyssey of Doctor Who novels will be disappointed. There’s some hard SF in here for sure, but his Second Doctor, Jamie and Zoe tale is Doctor Who to the core - both classic and new, oddly enough. Because while at times it’s so authentically Troughton-era that the world seems to fade to monochrome as you read it, at others Baxter seems to be auditioning as a scriptwriter for the new series. “Look! Skiing on Titan! Timey-wimey stuff! A Scottish robot! I can do silly!”
It’s no coincidence the book has a title similar to TV's “The Wheel In Space”. It’s set just a few decades earlier, and Baxter has fun showing Zoe’s discomfort in this familiar yet unfamiliar setting, as early human colonists struggle to mine one of Saturn’s moons. Of course, there’s something inside the moon they really shouldn’t disturb…
Yep, it’s classic Troughton base-under-siege stuff. But Baxter adds some sci-fi twists, solid science and a few gloriously unexpected continuity references. His characterisation of the regulars is spot on (usually… we did wince once when the Doctor says, “anyhow”), with Jamie and Zoe used extremely well.
The monsters are a bit bland and occasionally you wonder if some iffy plotting choices are supposed to be homage. And while it’s all highly entertaining, it is a slight shame that Baxter decides to bend his style to Who rather than making Who bend to his.
Dave Golder
Read our Doctor Who: The Krotons review .
Read our Doctor Who: Dark Horizons review (an Eleventh Doctor book by Jenny Colgan) .
Read our latest Doctor Who series 7 news .
There was "no version" of Sonic 3 that wouldn't include Live and Learn according to director Jeff Fowler: "The fans would hunt me down"
Amid Oscar buzz, Zoe Saldana opens up on her new perspective on Hollywood and why she's only really proud of Avatar and Emilia Pérez: "I think I just have to accept who I am as a creative person"
