Destiny 2 cheat maker sues Bungie for hacking its cheats

Destiny 2
(Image credit: Bungie)

Destiny 2 cheat maker AimJunkies has now countersued Bungie as part of the pair's ongoing legal battle, accusing the developer of hacking a private computer and breaking terms of service by reverse-engineering software after purchasing it under an alias. 

The newly minted lawsuit (hosted via The Game Post) lists multiple counterclaims filed on behalf of James May, an individual under AimJunkies, and Phoenix Digital, the group's parent company. The suit claims that Bungie accessed May's private computer and files without permission, and that it would have had to in order to obtain the evidence it presented in its own legal filings. 

These claims invoke the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act and point to an older version of Bungie's licensing agreement which, unlike the current version, doesn't contain a clause about checking certain files for anti-cheat purposes. The suit claims May signed Bungie's LSLA before this clause was added. 

This "unauthorized and clandestine surveillance of private records" is described as "intentional, malicious, and willful," and May is seeking "injunctive relief and damages." The claim would also see "any device or product in Bungie’s custody or control" that was involved in the alleged surveillance impounded, modified, or outright destroyed. 

Phoenix Digital's claims, meanwhile, focus on the terms of service for AimJunkies products. The company claims that an "employee or agent" of Bungie purchased AimJunkies' Destiny 2 cheats under the alias Martin Zeniu in early 2020, accepting the company's terms of service in the process. These terms prohibit any attempt to "modify, hack, decompile, disassemble, reverse engineer, derive source code, or create derivative works of our software," and Phoenix Digital is now accusing Bungie of just that. 

Both counterclaim plaintiffs are pushing for a trial by jury, not to mention a lengthy relief quest calling for Bungie and related parties to be barred from accessing May and Phoenix Digital's computers, and for it to transfer and then destroy all copies of the files it's allegedly reverse-engineered or otherwise obtained. 

These claims would need to be vetted and held up in court, but the fact that this countersuit was filed at all distinguishes this case from Bungie's previous legal battles against cheaters, like the $13.5 million settlement that came from its suit against Elite Boss Tech. Incidentally, that suit also cited Bungie's LSLA, dismissed Bungie's claims of copyright infringement, and was once set to go to trial. But simply put, AimJunkies' defense seems a bit more concrete, so the future of its case is much more up in the air. 

Bungie has also sued a Destiny 2 cheater who allegedly threatened to "burn down" the studio.  

Austin Wood
Senior writer

Austin has been a game journalist for 12 years, having freelanced for the likes of PC Gamer, Eurogamer, IGN, Sports Illustrated, and more while finishing his journalism degree. He's been with 12DOVE since 2019. They've yet to realize his position is a cover for his career-spanning Destiny column, and he's kept the ruse going with a lot of news and the occasional feature, all while playing as many roguelikes as possible.

Read more
Venom, Spider-Man, Peni Parker, Scarlet Witch, Magneto, and Storm pose in artwork for Marvel Rivals
Marvel Rivals devs lift bans on players mistakenly banned for cheating: "We do not and will not ban players who are playing fairly"
Players in GTA Online running businesses and playing missions
GTA publisher is suing a GTA Online website that lets you buy hacked accounts, which "risks upending the GTA 5 player experience"
Invisible Woman in her Marvel Rivals character reveal trailer, surrounded by projectiles
Marvel Rivals bans popular third-party plugin: "We deem this program as cheating," but "fear not" if you've been using it
Key art for Dark and Darker.
2 years after Dark and Darker was first pulled from Steam, Korean court rules that developer Ironmace must pay Nexon $5.87 million for trade secret infringement
Key art for Destiny 2's Heresy Episode.
"A fun example of a bug becoming a feature": Destiny 2 accidentally made Exotic Glaives free to all classes, and Bungie says "we're going to let this ride"
Fortnite character Jonesy looks shocked in the story trailer for Season X.
Fortnite is now giving cheaters "second chances" with 1-year bans that allow you to use the battle royale like it's Discord and do absolutely nothing else until you're freed from the void
Latest in Destiny
Key art for Destiny 2's Heresy Episode.
"A fun example of a bug becoming a feature": Destiny 2 accidentally made Exotic Glaives free to all classes, and Bungie says "we're going to let this ride"
Destiny 2 Episode 3 Heresy screenshot of Eris Morn
Destiny 2's new Episode suggested the upcoming Apollo expansion will launch on July 15, but that date has mysteriously been scrubbed from the game
Destiny 2 Guardian in Taken energy
Bungie yanked Destiny 2 servers offline for emergency maintenance as Episode 3: Heresy got off to a rocky start, but it looks like we're back in business
Destiny 2 Star Wars armor sets
"Oryx is back": Destiny 2's final Episode takes the MMO to the site of the iconic Taken King expansion for a Coil-inspired roguelite mode, and also Star Wars armor
Destiny 2 guardian in scorn armor
How to get Destiny 2 Twitch Drops and link your accounts
Destiny 2 Kell's Fall art
The Destiny 2 dev behind Titan's game-changing Banner of War was also on its new Exotic shotgun Slayer's Fang: "I gotta live up to this, especially as my first gun"
Latest in News
Anthony Mackie in Captain America: Brave New World
Brave New World box office crosses milestone for Captain America movies, even though it still might not break even
Diego Luna as Cassian Andor
The first three episodes of the best Star Wars show are now available to watch for free ahead of the Andor season 2 premiere
Mio and Zoe holding a dragon during the trailer for Split Fiction.
Split Fiction blows It Takes Two out of the water by selling 1 million copies in 2 days, becoming Hazelight's fastest selling game ever
Death Stranding 2
Hideo Kojima says he'll "apologize beforehand" for Death Stranding 2 moments with Troy Baker's Higgs which are "so ridiculous" that "you'll probably throw the controller"
a stone giant walks on a field near a cliff
Erenshor, the 'MMORPG' with fake players that's not actually an MMO at all, gets an imminent release date
Michael Bay
Michael Bay and James Cameron had a call to commiserate over the state of the movie industry: "No one can greenlight anything anymore"