Colin McRae Dirt review

Now strangely lacking Colin McRae

12DOVE Verdict

Pros

  • +

    Gorgeous graphics

  • +

    Sheer variety of modes

  • +

    Excellent damage model

Cons

  • -

    Multiplayer is notably lacking

  • -

    Chugs on higher end rigs

  • -

    Announcing is irritating

Why you can trust 12DOVE Our experts review games, movies and tech over countless hours, so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about our reviews policy.

Simply put, Dirt is visually luxurious. This debut for Codemasters’ in-house Neon Engine (also being used for next year’s Race Driver One) is an impressive showcase for the obvious power behind the technology, making rival racing titles such asForza Motorsport 2look about as appealing as a tapeworm sandwich in comparison. So stunning are the locations, you’ll feel your neck redden under the heat of the desolate dustball tracks, and you’ll practically feel the moisture rising up through your socks as you zip around a waterlogged recreation of the forestry of Japan.

The benefits are certainly more than just cosmetic, mind you; weak side-barriers that would previously not be moved now crumple under impact, and if you’re so inclined you can break your way through them. And better news is that they’ve managed to sort out those framerate issues we detected in early preview versions - the action purrs along as though powered by pure silk, meaning there’s only one possible way it can all end - by us breaking out the full stops and declaring Dirt the best looking racing game ever.

And it plays a mean game of, er, rally as well, although the biggest fans of the previous McRae offerings might be the last to appreciate it. See, the word “rally” hasn’t been omitted from the title by accident - Dirt instead fancies itself as the roughhouse version of TOCA. Rallycross, hill climbs, buggy racing - if there’s a chance it’ll splash mud in your face, there’s every chance it’s featured in Dirt. So, does this expansion into other areas of racing dilute the core rallying experience of previous games? Well, in a way, we’re afraid it does.

While the general level of track design is a step above the disappointing McRae ’05, there’s still an inescapable feeling that the handling has been dumbed down to give newcomers the ability to drive more than 400km without their front wheels falling off. Judging this from a neutral perspective (i.e, from the POV of those that don’t live and breathe mud), this is unequivocally a positive move for the series, but Colin McRae: Dirt ’s new-found thirst for mainstream acceptance may leave long-term fans feeling like their well has run dry.

The benefits are certainly more than just cosmetic, mind you; weak side-barriers that would previously not be moved now crumple under impact, and if you’re so inclined you can break your way through them. And better news is that they’ve managed to sort out those framerate issues we detected in early preview versions - the action purrs along as though powered by pure silk, meaning there’s only one possible way it can all end - by us breaking out the full stops and declaring Dirt the best looking racing game ever.

And it plays a mean game of, er, rally as well, although the biggest fans of the previous McRae offerings might be the last to appreciate it. See, the word “rally” hasn’t been omitted from the title by accident - Dirt instead fancies itself as the roughhouse version of TOCA. Rallycross, hill climbs, buggy racing - if there’s a chance it’ll splash mud in your face, there’s every chance it’s featured in Dirt. So, does this expansion into other areas of racing dilute the core rallying experience of previous games? Well, in a way, we’re afraid it does.

While the general level of track design is a step above the disappointing McRae ’05, there’s still an inescapable feeling that the handling has been dumbed down to give newcomers the ability to drive more than 400km without their front wheels falling off. Judging this from a neutral perspective (i.e, from the POV of those that don’t live and breathe mud), this is unequivocally a positive move for the series, but Colin McRae: Dirt ’s new-found thirst for mainstream acceptance may leave long-term fans feeling like their well has run dry.

Simply put, Dirt is visually luxurious. This debut for Codemasters’ in-house Neon Engine (also being used for next year’s Race Driver One) is an impressive showcase for the obvious power behind the technology, making rival racing titles such asForza Motorsport 2look about as appealing as a tapeworm sandwich in comparison. So stunning are the locations, you’ll feel your neck redden under the heat of the desolate dustball tracks, and you’ll practically feel the moisture rising up through your socks as you zip around a waterlogged recreation of the forestry of Japan.

The benefits are certainly more than just cosmetic, mind you; weak side-barriers that would previously not be moved now crumple under impact, and if you’re so inclined you can break your way through them. And better news is that they’ve managed to sort out those framerate issues we detected in early preview versions - the action purrs along as though powered by pure silk, meaning there’s only one possible way it can all end - by us breaking out the full stops and declaring Dirt the best looking racing game ever.

And it plays a mean game of, er, rally as well, although the biggest fans of the previous McRae offerings might be the last to appreciate it. See, the word “rally” hasn’t been omitted from the title by accident - Dirt instead fancies itself as the roughhouse version of TOCA. Rallycross, hill climbs, buggy racing - if there’s a chance it’ll splash mud in your face, there’s every chance it’s featured in Dirt. So, does this expansion into other areas of racing dilute the core rallying experience of previous games? Well, in a way, we’re afraid it does.

While the general level of track design is a step above the disappointing McRae ’05, there’s still an inescapable feeling that the handling has been dumbed down to give newcomers the ability to drive more than 400km without their front wheels falling off. Judging this from a neutral perspective (i.e, from the POV of those that don’t live and breathe mud), this is unequivocally a positive move for the series, but Colin McRae: Dirt ’s new-found thirst for mainstream acceptance may leave long-term fans feeling like their well has run dry.

The benefits are certainly more than just cosmetic, mind you; weak side-barriers that would previously not be moved now crumple under impact, and if you’re so inclined you can break your way through them. And better news is that they’ve managed to sort out those framerate issues we detected in early preview versions - the action purrs along as though powered by pure silk, meaning there’s only one possible way it can all end - by us breaking out the full stops and declaring Dirt the best looking racing game ever.

And it plays a mean game of, er, rally as well, although the biggest fans of the previous McRae offerings might be the last to appreciate it. See, the word “rally” hasn’t been omitted from the title by accident - Dirt instead fancies itself as the roughhouse version of TOCA. Rallycross, hill climbs, buggy racing - if there’s a chance it’ll splash mud in your face, there’s every chance it’s featured in Dirt. So, does this expansion into other areas of racing dilute the core rallying experience of previous games? Well, in a way, we’re afraid it does.

While the general level of track design is a step above the disappointing McRae ’05, there’s still an inescapable feeling that the handling has been dumbed down to give newcomers the ability to drive more than 400km without their front wheels falling off. Judging this from a neutral perspective (i.e, from the POV of those that don’t live and breathe mud), this is unequivocally a positive move for the series, but Colin McRae: Dirt ’s new-found thirst for mainstream acceptance may leave long-term fans feeling like their well has run dry.

More info

GenreRacing
DescriptionMuddy rally racer tools through rural environments, frequently leaving the pavement behind to fishtail to victory.
Platform"Xbox 360","PS3","PC"
US censor rating"Rating Pending","Rating Pending","Rating Pending"
UK censor rating"","",""
Release date1 January 1970 (US), 1 January 1970 (UK)
More
CATEGORIES
Latest in Racing
Mario Kart 8 Deluxe
Nintendo knows you're waiting for Mario Kart 9, but it still wants you to run a million laps in Mario Kart 8 first
Wheel World
The spirit of Burnout Paradise lives on in this fabulous bicycle racing game from the makers of my favorite indie fighting game – a true Steam Next Fest gem
Sonic Racing CrossWorlds
Sonic Racing CrossWorlds announcement trailer proves Sega is coming for Mario Kart 9's throne with transforming cars and a closed beta this month
Need For Speed Unbound
The Need For Speed series is pumping the brakes as "Criterion are joining their colleagues working on Battlefield" instead of tuning more cars
Forza Horizon 5 the real deal reasonably priced car seasonal championship volvo 850 R racing
Forza Horizon 5 is the latest Xbox game to make the leap to PS5, and it's launching this spring with all of the same content and DLC
Tokyo Xtreme Racer
Cult classic racing series returns 18 years after its once-final entry on Xbox 360 to 95% overwhelmingly positive Steam reviews
Latest in Reviews
The pump header of the NZXT Kraken Elite 360 RGB showing a 35 degree cpu
NZXT Kraken Elite 360 RGB review: "Has some solid design points that make installation a lot easier"
Logitech G Pro X TKL Rapid gaming keyboard on a wooden desk with blue lighting
Logitech G Pro X TKL Rapid review: "one of the best value Hall effect gaming keyboards out there"
Millie Bobby Brown and Chris Pratt in The Electric State
The Electric State review: "Although this may be their most visually stunning movie yet, it looks like the Russos are yet to find their footing outside of the MCU"
Doggerland player board
Doggerland review: "A delicate dance of survival and management that doesn't feel weighted toward a single strategy"
Logitech G Pro X Superlight 2 DEX gaming mouse standing upright on a wooden desk
Logitech G Pro X Superlight 2 DEX review: "a force to be reckoned with"
Daredevil: Born Again
Daredevil: Born Again season 1 review: "There have been far worse Marvel projects, but few as disappointing as this"