A developer on Spelunky, one of the most acclaimed roguelikes of all time, says that developing for that genre is "more interesting" than in others.
Earlier this week George Fan, creator of Plants vs Zombies, released a new puzzle game, Hardhat Wombat. While speaking to 12DOVE about it, Fan discussed the nature of puzzle development, and the need to deliberately account for different types of solutions. That stands in contrast to some of Fan's other work, like PvZ, in which he says "the gameplay was random enough" to keep the testing process fresh.
"I think a lot of the reason people enjoy working on roguelikes," he says, "is that as a developer of the game, you can play the game a lot like a player would." The idea is that thanks to random maps and upgrades, a roguelike will rarely play the same way twice, and that makes testing the game inherently different every time it's played, whether by a player or a QA tester.
Thankfully, I didn't have to take Fan's word for it. His development partner on Hardhat Wombat was Andy Hull, lead programmer on Spelunky, a game still treated as one of the best roguelikes of all time. When I put Fan's comments to Hull via email, he admitted that finding a new approach for every new testing playthrough had been something of a challenge.
"Making a puzzle game like Hardhat Wombat does really require you to consciously try and remind yourself of what a new player would be experiencing. After solving each level once [...] it was very hard to judge the difficulty of the puzzle precisely." Hull says he'd "fall into bad habits" during testing by constantly approaching each puzzle the same way - "I had to force myself to try odd solutions to make sure everything was working correctly."
On Spelunky, however, things were slightly different. Hull says that "because the experience was random each time, I was more likely to naturally try new tactics and combinations. Playing random levels is certainly more interesting when you spend so many hours testing during development." The unfortunate payoff, however, is the amount of time that adds to things like bug fixing, as it gets harder to find all the potential variants of a specific means of playing.
For all that complexity, the inherent variety does seem to keep developers and players coming back. Spelunky might be close to the peak of the genre, but the roguelike has a rich history and remains a hugely exciting part of the indie scene today.
Don't believe us? Check out our list of the best roguelikes.
Balatro creator reacts to The Game Awards noms by telling you to play other indie games that weren't nominated: "I just happen to be the lucky one to be propped up"
Finally, our first look at the chaotic gameplay footage of The Binding of Isaac multiplayer, the online update we've been waiting a decade for
