50 Actors Who Nearly Played Iconic Roles

Tom Cruise could have been... Iron Man (Iron Man)

The Part: The Marvel Universe could have looked very different indeed had the numerous discussions held between Kevin Feige and Tom Cruise resulted in the toothy A-lister playing billionaire Tony Stark.

How They Would've Played It:
If it’s possible, try and imagine Tony Stark as even more smug…

Why We're Glad They Didn't Get It: Downey also brings a good amount of smug to the table, but it’s offset by humour in spades. His comic timing is perfect.

Sean Connery could have been... Gandalf (The Lord Of The Rings)

The Part: The wise old wizard at the heart of the Lord Of The Rings saga, and now also The Hobbit .

How They Would’ve Played It: “Good morning Mishter Bagginsh. We leave at sunshet.” Etc. etc.

Why We're Glad They Didn't Get It:
Sir Ian McKellen’s dulcet tones are now inseparable from the character. “You shall not PASH!” wouldn’t have worked quite so well.

Jack Nicholson could have been... Michael Corleone (The Godfather)

The Part: The beloved son of Don Vito Corleone could have been played by none other than Jack Nicholson, who eventually dropped out, claiming he didn’t feel the role was right for him.

How They Would’ve Played It:
We could certainly have bought Nicholson as a murderous Mafioso, although he might have been a bit more flamboyant than Al Pacino.

Why We're Glad They Didn't Get It: We agree with Nicholson’s verdict. While the role wasn’t quite right for him, it was absolutely perfect for Pacino.

Molly Ringwald could have been... Vivian Ward (Pretty Woman)

The Part: Tart with a heart Vivian falls in love with a wealthy punter who basically remodels her entire personality. That’s romance, kids!

How They Would’ve Played It: It’s a strange one to imagine, but Ringwald is a much tougher customer than Roberts. Her Vivian would certainly have had more edge.

Why We're Glad They Didn't Get It: Like it or not, Vivian’s primary characteristic is her sweet nature, and that sits better with Miss Roberts than it does Miss Ringwald.

Gwyneth Paltrow could have been... Rose DeWitt Bukater (Titanic)

The Part: One half of Titanic ’s doomed love story, it was a role that won Kate Winslet an Oscar nomination.

How They Would’ve Played It: With a similar dose of tremulous emotion, but possibly a tad more steel.

Why We're Glad They Didn't Get It: Winslet and DiCaprio’s chemistry was impeccable. We wouldn’t want to tinker with it, thank you very much.

Tom Cruise could have been... Ferris Bueller (Ferris Bueller's Day Off)

The Part: A teenage slacker extraordinaire, Ferris is the role that made Matthew Broderick a star.

How They Would’ve Played It: Remember Risky Business ? Like that, basically.

Why We're Glad They Didn't Get It: Cruise’s toothy charm probably would have worked, but Broderick is extremely likeable, serving up warmth and cool in equal measure.

Alec Baldwin could have been... Richard Kimble (The Fugitive)

The Part: Having already missed out on continuing as Jack Ryan to Harrison Ford, Alec Baldwin was also offered the lead in The Fugitive , only to turn it down!

How They Would’ve Played It:
Casting Baldwin opposite Tommy Lee Jones would have produced a right old snarl-off. Alas, it wasn’t to be.

Why We're Glad They Didn't Get It: Before becoming something of a comedy icon, Baldwin’s characters weren’t half as likeable as they are now. Ford was the primo leading man back then for a reason.

Warren Beatty could have been... Gordon Gekko (Wall Street)

The Part: Notoriously choosy in his roles, Beatty passed on the role of slippery corporate shitheel Gordon Gekko, allowing Michael Douglas to steal in and make the role his own.

How They Would’ve Played It: In Beatty’s hands, its possible that Gekko could have come across as even less likeable than Douglas’ incarnation.

Why We're Glad They Didn't Get It: While Beatty does brash and bluff very well, nobody could be oilier than Douglas is here.

Sean Connery could have been... Morpheus (The Matrix)

The Part: Connery was also wanted as the wise old sage of The Matrix , but he passed up on that one as well. Ah well…

How They Would’ve Played It:
Probably with a little less cool than Laurence Fishburne, but with a few more enigmatic tics thrown in for good measure.

Why We're Glad They Didn't Get It: Connery famously “didn’t get” either LOTR or The Matrix . Which makes you think it was probably for the best, really…

Julia Roberts could have been... Catherine Trammell (Basic Instinct)

The Part: Sharon Stone’s leg-crossing femme fatale. Handy with an ice pick.

How They Would’ve Played It:
Instead of being an ice-cold uber-bitch, Roberts’ Trammell would have been a twee girl next door with a terrible secret.

Why We're Glad They Didn't Get It: There’s no way in hell that scene would have made it into the final cut!

George Wales

George was once GamesRadar's resident movie news person, based out of London. He understands that all men must die, but he'd rather not think about it. But now he's working at Stylist Magazine.

Latest in Movies
Theo James as Hal in Osgood Perkins' The Monkey
It might only be March, but Stephen King adaptation The Monkey is now the highest grossing horror movie of 2025
Cyborg and Batman together
Justice League stars Ray Fisher and Ben Affleck are teaming up for new thriller Animals
Batman and Catwoman talking
Robert Pattinson is hoping to team up with his The Batman co-star Zoe Kravitz on another project soon
Keanu Reeves and Brzrkr
Justin Lin to helm Keanu Reeves' comic book movie adaptation BRZRKR for Netflix
Train to Busan passengers
Train to Busan director is returning to the horror sub-genre with a new movie described as the culmination of his zombie universe
Thomas Shelby on a horse
Although Netflix is making the Peaky Blinders movie, fans need not to worry as it will be released in theaters too
Latest in Features
Monster Hunter Wilds characters share a meal
Oh no, Monster Hunter Wilds is so good that I'm already counting the days until its inevitable Master Rank expansion
Kai and Giatta battle Xaurip in Avowed
I get why Obsidian doesn't like The Elder Scrolls comparisons, but Avowed is the first RPG to have its hooks in me this deep since Skyrim took over my life 14 years ago
Photo taken by writer Rosalie Newcombe of the Tears of the Kingdom OLED Nintendo Switch handheld, with the Super Mario Nendoroid figure standing in front of it.
My PC is screaming for an update, but the Switch 2 will be taking all my money this year
GoDice in their RPG case beside Pixels dice
I put two electronic d20s head-to-head and the bad news for your wallet is the discount D&D dice failed its saving throw
Arydia: The Paths We Dare Tread in play
This board game TRPG hybrid delivers something D&D hasn't quite managed to capture for me
Daredevil: Born Again
Daredevil: Born Again killing off a fan-favorite character is controversial, but it might prove to be the right choice for the new Marvel show